Just had a strange experience with a taste test.
I should preface this by saying that I’m hardly a Sommelier (wine or coffee). I’m not going to be able to pick out a specific region or variety in a blind tasting. However, I’ve done a few coffee cuppings and wine tastings — my palette isn’t complete devoid of taste.
I got a new bag of beans yesterday and still had enough for a cup from my last bag, so I thought I’d do a comparison.
Cup 1
1 month old
Nicaraguan single origin
Light roast
Origin Coffee Roasters
Cup 2
Roasted this week
Ethiopian single origin
Medium roast
Moonroast Coffee Roasters
Both cups made with a AeroPress using The Hoff’s ultimate recipe.
Although one was made after the other, I made sure they were the same temperate for tasting.
…They tasted the same…
I was expecting at least something to differentiate them. Different regions, different roasters, different roasting level, different age… nothing.
I know the AeroPress is a “forgiving” brewing method, but I didn’t think it removed all character from the cup.
I asked my wife to try them both without telling her what I was doing and she thought they were the same brew.
So either we’re both about to come down with COVID; by some miracle these two different beans have ended up with the same flavour profile; or something about my method has stripped the nuance out of the cup.
Any ideas?