Right..... that's that finished
Here's some spoiler free thoughts. Starting with the negative....
1) It's not as scary as TEW1. I always felt 1 was scary because (for the first half of the game anyway) you felt it could be kinda real. Real stuff was happening. 2 feels like a video game from the get go in terms of the story, environment and enemies.
2) It's a little glitchy in places. The "quick sneak up and kill" skill you unlock seems to fail just as frequently as it works. Mainly if you're in a cluttered environment.
3) The final few chapters lack polish. No blame here. I know how game development works. Just saying what it is. 2D planes instead of models and invisible walls where you should clearly be able to run/walk/hide/go. It's nothing that will make you throw the controller down in disgust, but it's a shame.
4) Story is very disjointed. Changing tack half way through, just felt weird to me, like they didn't have enough good story for 1 game, so they put 2 weaker stories together.
Still, the positives....
1) Great length to the game. Took me ages to finish due to thoroughness, but I guess most people will be getting 10+ hours out of it.
2) Looks great. Don't care what system you're on, it's a nice looking game.
3) And the most major positive of all, it's STILL great masses of fun running around and shooting and sneaking and killing baddies. Some of the mid-bosses are annoying, but generally I had a blast from beginning to end.
Now..... do I play New Game+ or start again on Nightmare?
I feel getting some of the extra trophies will be easier on NG+, however that won't allow me to get the one for finishing the game on Nightmare or above

Decisions decisions.