Unreal Tournament 3 Black edition 10/20
I played this back in 2009 (going by the date on my savegame) but stopped for some reason during Act2, picked it up again over the past week:
+Looks reasonable considering its age, decent gore etc
+Runs well 150-450fps maxed out
+Decent range of weapons albeit not that innovative
+Deathmatch is good fun, some of the CTF not bad
+Cutscenes are quite well designed from a visual perspective....
-....however the dialogue is terrible, horribly cliched and you don't build any rapport with the characters really
-Plus the ending is terrible, I won't post any spoilers but it feels like the sort of turning point you'd expect three quarters of the way through something, not right at the end, and leaves lots of questions unanswered.
-Rocket launcher is rubbish, rockets far too slow
-Some of the Warfare maps are a massive chore, very attritional where you are constantly running/surfing back and forth between nodes. I tended to use my Cards on those to speed things up a bit
-Likewise one or two of the vehicle-oriented CTF levels dragged quite a bit, I think I won one of them 1-0.
-The campaign mostly feels like what it is, a bunch of random levels strung together and the token voiceover between missions doesn't really do anything to tie it together into a cohesive story. Of course, that's not really what the UT series is about, but it's one of those situations where you kind of wish they handn't bothered and just make the levels selectable by number from a menu.
Overall it doesn't feel like a game I will come back to, one of those you grind to the finish and then put down forever.