I like Laphroaig, quite a lot. Then again, peaty, smoky whisky is pretty much my favourite type. Stuff that's a bit like chewing a burned table leg. Yum! Certainly not to everybody's taste. I'm sure I would have hated it in my teens.
I'm pretty sure you won't like Lagavulin or Ardbeg much either.
In other news, I found out that the Ardbeg Uigeadail I tried got Jim Murray's 2009 award for World Whisky of the Year (the Ardbeg 10 got it in 2008). Definitely was good stuff - about £40 a bottle though.
Ardbeg was closed from the 80s until 1997. That means a lot of recent Ardbed 10 yo (mine cost £28) bottlings have actually been considerably older (age rated Scotch Wisky refers to the guarenteed youngest stuff in there). We'll have to see if the quality stays up there when they're back to really using 10 year old whisky, which should start happening about now. I wonder if my bottle is really mutton dressed as lamb? Need to get my Lagavulin 16 yo drank before I start it.