Poll: The Official X-Factor Thread!

[ps3ud0]

In all honesty, having Beyonce next to Alex really ruined what I thought of Alex, I thought she was actually VERY good, but I didnt have that barometer until tonight and it shows how unfortunately shes not...

Shes good, but not special...

ps3ud0

 

[Pigeon_Killer]

In all honesty, having Beyonce next to Alex really ruined what I thought of Alex, I thought she was actually VERY good, but I didnt have that barometer until tonight and it shows how unfortunately shes not...

Could it not be that she is very good and Beyonce's just better?

 

[tisonlyme]

What a way to make a credible song instantly lose credibility

Having said that, I prefer the JLS version, it doesn't need to be belted out Alexandra style

 

[fozzybear]

In all honesty, having Beyonce next to Alex really ruined what I thought of Alex, I thought she was actually VERY good, but I didnt have that barometer until tonight and it shows how unfortunately shes not...

Shes good, but not special...

ps3ud0

Remember Alex is only 20. She's barely out a foot wrong throughout the series.

Still hasn't got the whole package like Leona though.

Cheryl will help swing it Alex's way.

 

[ps3ud0]

Could it not be that she is very good and Beyonce's just better?

Or that I would buy something by Beyonce and not by Alex?

I think thats the differentiation that matters

ps3ud0

 

[Keyser Soze]

That is one of my favorite songs of all time, but both versions are carp.

If you are going to download this song tonight why not download Jeff Buckley's version or one of the many covers out there that are a lot better.

 

[Keyser Soze]

What a way to make a credible song instantly lose credibility

Having said that, I prefer the JLS version, it doesn't need to be belted out Alexandra style

well said

 

[Nodiggidy123]

i agree.
whilst i want alex to win, i did prefer the jls version.

 

[suarve]

In all honesty, having Beyonce next to Alex really ruined what I thought of Alex, I thought she was actually VERY good, but I didnt have that barometer until tonight and it shows how unfortunately shes not...

Shes good, but not special...

ps3ud0

Personally thought they sounded very similar. Now imagine Diana or suarve singing with Beyonce and they'd both be lost.

Could barely hear Eoghen when he sang with the boyband tonight, his voice was totally drowned out imo.

 

[Keyser Soze]

I thought it showed how all three acts were inferior tbh

 

[meghatronic]

Could barely hear Eoghen when he sang with the boyband tonight, his voice was totally drowned out imo.

I believe that was intentional... as in, he's ****.

 

[Kell_ee001]

I don't like that Alex pays no attention when Dermot is talking. She's too busy declaring her love to Cheryl

 

[tsinc80697]

anyone been trying to vote? girlfriend sat here trying to vote for JLS and shes been trying to for about 15minutes, constant busy tone? But as soon as you use a mobile (twice as much money to ITV) it goes straight through, ridiculous!

 

[pabloB]

Hate all of this type of thing but would be good to see the Group win. This Alex just seems like another Leona Lewis to me!

 

[meghatronic]

I don't like Alex

Fixed

 

[Kell_ee001]

They kept saying on the Xtra factor that the lines were crazy busy.

 

[meghatronic]

I've gone back on youtube, and JLS have done some good songs really... I think they're more "special" than Alex.

 

[tsinc80697]

Hate all of this type of thing but would be good to see the Group win. This Alex just seems like another Leona Lewis to me!

alex is just a mini leona who in turn is a mini beyonce. Beyonce showed Alex how its really done before, showed her up I thought. Yes shes young etc but her voice just doesnt come close to leona or beyonce

 

[Dave85]

I wanted Eoghan to win

 

[Kell_ee001]

Fixed

I don't dislike her and I do think she's talented, I just don't think she should win And it's the second time she's done that to Dermot - very rude!

I wanted Eoghan to win

Me too.... but we were definatily in a minority!