Well it's been what, 5 months since I posted in here last? I've been running a 3070ti since my last post and today I finally made the effort to see what is actually up with my Vega. Before I was having black screen crashes but that seems to have went away, in the end it just plain sucked in terms of temperature.
I ordered x2 3mm, x2 2mm and x2 1.5mm, x2 1mm thermal pads from Grizzly as well as some more MX-4 paste since I was all out. Here is my results: *****
After scouring various forums trying to get an idea of what pads to use I had mixed suggestions, I started with the 3mm on the VRMs and 1.5mm everywhere else. Soon as I put the sink on to test the contact there was no way the heatsink was going to even contact the die. I ripped off the 3mm and put on the 2mm on the VRMs and that was much better, but could see the card was 100% going to have a bend due to the height of the 1.5mm pads, so I dropped them to the 1mm pads. With this I can see everything is flush and looks like contact is perfect. So I fire it up and it runs great first few benches, then hotspot starts to hit 105c under full load but the GPU temp never goes past 75. The card still throttles like hell, and now all my idle temps are like 50c across the board, with VRMs idling at 52c.
I took it back apart and can see the contact between the VRM and pads is not great, very little impression on the pad. The little spot between the GPU package and HBM, the paste has basically hardened to a crust. It hardened, in an hour of benching. I know this is a curing paste but god damn.
So I strip it down again, it looks like the contact between the VRM and pads is due to a slightly too thick (1mm lol) pads elsewhere, so I took a exacto knife blade and took a few pencil shavings off the 1mm pads. Re-done the paste just so it was perfect. I rebooted and went back to benching. Much lower overall idle temps, basically 30-35 across the board. Under full load the hotspot was still hitting 105c and the card throttling. Except now that when the benchmark ended the temperatures very quickly came down to 40c or so, so that's a positive.
The card still runs like ******* due to throttling, even with a -10% power tuning and underclock it still runs hot as hell.
At this point I've tried every size of thermal pad (I originally had Artic pads on there) to get good contact, followed online advice for the paste application and how to tighten the heatsink correctly to ensure paste gets into all the important bits and nada.
I'm glad I gave up on the card when I did, I'm half tempted to just punt it off for sale for a couple hundred and state that it's only suitable for mining with a huge undervolt.