The Ups and Downs of high-bar squatting

Dreamforger said:
It's more the pain in the hips that's the concern atm and it's possible that this has been contributing to the knee clicks and whatnot. However that does not necessarily mean that sumo has been the cause, as it could have also been a technique issue high bar squatting that has caused the hip issue and that has carried over. I might stop sumo for a while to see if things improve because things aren't feeling too brilliant today (better than last night though).
Click to expand...

Doesn't sound pleasant, and sorry to hear it. :(

The issue may well be caused by the "knees out" cue, which caused me huge problems with my squatting. If you don't use it then ignore. :D

I found that as soon as I stopped trying for "knees out" and both feet parallel, etc., my knees and hips stopped hurting and I could squat a lot more (and my legs and glutes suddenly became even bigger... Which wreaked havoc in other areas). And no, my back didn't suddenly explode, and neither did my knees. Aaaaaaaanyway.

You are experienced enough a lifter to work out what works for YOU and your own quirks/skeletal structure, etc. so if something works for you and you lift more doing it, who cares what other people are doing? :)
 
mrthingyx said:
Doesn't sound pleasant, and sorry to hear it. :(

The issue may well be caused by the "knees out" cue.

I found that as soon as I stopped trying for "knees out" ...I could squat a lot more (and my legs and glutes suddenly became even bigger...
Click to expand...

I'll be dammed if that is the case but it would make sense as it is a very similar motion to opening the hips in a sumo deadlift position to get hips as close to the bar as possible (which is the main time I notice this odd hip problem). I focused heavily on knees out because it initially stopped the knee clicking, but so did stretching out the hamstring. So what I think has happened is that all the time I thought I had to squat with "knees out" to stop the knee click due to a bad hip (when actually it was tight hamstring), the hips have overcompensated and have almost replicated the same symptoms, even though there is nothing actually wrong with the hips or the hamstrings now; just instead I'm left with the side effects. This however does not change that I'm (as far as I'm currently concerned) not built for sumo deadlifts due to limb lengths etc.

I've been told to lay off the squats until at least Sunday as I was diagnosed with acute tendonitis that is easily cured with rest. I'll aim for squatting on Monday to be safe, and I'll just focus on not letting the knees come in rather than keeping them out. Another thing I have been told for a long time is that my "knees out" motion was excessive in comparison to other lifters, but as I mentioned that this initially was the only way to stop the knee clicking in the beginning.

Also, in for quad gains!
 
i think "knees out" works for certain people and anatomies, but have a look at the "Chinese" method of squatting, where the knees are drawn in slightly.

If you keep yourself really upright and don't shoot your hips back in the concentric part of the squat, you may well suddenly find lifting heavy stuff suddenly doesn't seem anywhere near as heavy anymore...

And you will suffer some of the worst quad DOMS of your life. :D
 
mrthingyx said:
i think "knees out" works for certain people and anatomies, but have a look at the "Chinese" method of squatting, where the knees are drawn in slightly.

If you keep yourself really upright and don't shoot your hips back in the concentric part of the squat, you may well suddenly find lifting heavy stuff suddenly doesn't seem anywhere near as heavy anymore...

And you will suffer some of the worst quad DOMS of your life. :D
Click to expand...

Apparently the reason for this in the Chinese weightlifting team is because if that is the strongest position for your body to be in, then that is the position you should be in.

I try to stay as upright as possible but I have a natural lean forward, so that doesn't help anything. At least my hips don't shoot back and up as if I changed my mind of performing a squat and thought I'll try good morning instead.
 
29/5/15 - Friday

Bench and OHP, no squats.

Bench

Bar x lots
40kg x 8
50kg x 2x4
60kg x 2x2
65kg x 8 - Might have been 9

More annoyed that I lost count more than anything. Since I can't guarantee it was 9 I'll keep the weight the same for next week and then hopefully I'll get at least 9 reps at the end of next week for sure.

OHP

Bar x lots
27.5kg x 6
36kg x 3x3
32.5kg x 3x6

I could have got 3x8 on the last working weight but the scapular wasn't sliding the way it (they) should have so I chose to play it safe.

Dumbbell Bench Press

15kg x 3x12

could have handled more weight but wanted to focus on simultaneous contraction again. I wanted a 4th set but there was a bit of clicking in the left elbow and around the scapular so I decided to leave it.

And that's that, nice simple session. Nothing too exciting but I seem to be making gradual progress on both lifts currently.
 
31/5/15 - Sunday

Deadlifts, conventional deadlifts.

Deadlifts knee pulls

60kg x 5
75kg x 4
90kg x 4
105kg x 2x3
112.5kg x 5x2

Deadlift block pulls 3"

105kg x 2x4
120kg x 2x3
135kg(B,S) x 4x2

After 14 sets of deadlifts I felt justified to use straps as initially I managed 135kg for a single and then missed it. I put the straps on and the weight went up ok with goof form too.

I could not be bothered doing anything else, especially where I'm supposed to be squatting tomorrow too!
 
1/6/15 - Monday

Squats (Not really), Bench and OHP. I still can't squat so I'm seriously grumpy.

Squats

Bar x billions
40kg x millions
60kg x thousands
80kg x 2x2

I genuinely have no idea how many reps I did but I did just enough for the knee to work but I would stop as soon as I felt a click, a clunk or if it felt like something moved. By all means I ca squat but I'm choosing not to until the knee is feeling awesome. I sat in a squat position with a bar resting on my knees for about 3 minutes and squats after that felt pretty good but it felt like there was pressure in my right knee so I just left it. I'll try again on Wednesday or Thursday. Looks like I'm going to be a bro for the week and bench and deadlift.

Bench

Bar x lots
40kg x 8
50kg x 2x4
60kg x 3
67.5kg x 4x3
55kg x 3x8

I had to play around with the grip quite a bit since I'm at a new gym and the bars are slightly different to the ones I'm used to. I think I found the right grip for me. The working sets were a tad slow but yet really easy, so that's a good thing, right?

OHP

Bar x lots
25kg x 8
30kg x 4
35kg x 5
32.5kg x 5
30kg x 8

Put my wrist wraps on and for some reason made the reps so much easier. I guess my wrist must be bending back slightly.

Dumbbell incline bench press

15kg x 5x12

Still a tad wobbly but the weight is super easy.

Chest supported/t-bar row machine

Bar x lots
Bar + 10kg x 15
Bar + 20kg x 12
Bar + 27.5kg x 2x12

Lower back started to ache and tbh, I just couldn't be bothered. Not being able to squat properly had ticked me off so much.

So squats are being put aside for now and I shall just focus on bench, OHP and deadlifts. Time to rest, eat lots of chocolates because I'm being grumpy and deadlift tomorrow!
 
mrthingyx said:
What clicks (which part of the knee) and how long has it clicked for? Previous injuries?
Click to expand...

Gamefreak501 said:
A friend of mine has a rotated knee cap. Similar to the symptoms you have - have you spoken to a Doctor about it?
Click to expand...

I initially had little clicks around a year ago, just air escaping, nothing painful or to be concerned about, especially where it would go once the joint was warm. It would also go if my hamstring was stretched enough.

Roll on December 2014. Excessive month of 14/15 hour days sat programming, no training, no stretching and no mobility. When I went back to training end of December for a week or 2 and then starting again in February the "click" had progressed to what felt like muscles and tendons under the knee pulling the femur and patella out of place. This has progressed ever since (has got worse and better during different periods).

Initially I thought it was hip problem. It wasn't, but focusing on it did help. This resulted in throwing my knees out super wide, and sure enough it went as long as I could keep my knees out all the time. This just wasn't possible with heavier weights. The problem then persisted and I found it would go with a lot of hamstring stretching as the area behind the knee was extremely tight. I also found that the tissue the femur meets the glute was knotted and upon releasing that also helped. However, whilst focusing on this it turned out that my calves and ankles had (slightly) tightened, but that only impacted the tightness of the hamstrings. However, due the reduced ROM in the squat could have aided to whatever is currently going on, rather than because of tight ankles.

I'm trying to avoid doing too much reading on the interwebs about the problem because most articles instantly jump to a problem with the ACL. I however do not think it's the ACL as there is no real pain, no inflammation, and I still have full range of knee motion.

I'm going to try and see a physio tomorrow about it and I may go to the doctors if the physio recommends it.
 
3/6/15 - Wednesday

Bench and deadlifts. Warmed up with some bar squats and some weightlifting style dynamic stuff. A minor click in the knee but so much better! Few more days should do it! I might even leave it until net week but do something like leg extensions, GHR, back extensions and good mornings to strengthen the hamstrings and the muscles around the knees.

Deadlifts

60kg x 5
80kg x 3
100kg x 3
115kg x 3
127.5kg(B,S) x 6 - Yay

I was disappointed at first (had another 1-2 in me but thought I'd leave it) but it turns out that the calculator proposed a higher max than what I got last week so an improvement is an improvement!

Deadlift Knee-Pulls

75kg x 4
90kg x 4
105kg x 5x4

Mainly DOH, the last 2 sets were mixed grip.

Bench

Bar x lots
40kg x 8
47.5kg x 2x6
55kg x 2x5
65kg x 2x3
72.5kg x 2x1

Nailed it! Misgrooved the first 72.5kg but went up super easy regardless. The second one looked slower but it was a lot more controlled coming down onto the chest and it absolute flew up.

Dumbbell Flyes

10kg x 4x12

And that's that.

Really happy with how everything went. Admittedly actually getting another 2 reps on the main working set of deadlifts would have been nice but never mind, progress is progress. Bench seems to be coming along and it just looks like I need to get used to handling heavier weight, rather than trying to do it for billions of reps.

I shall go in for a super light session tomorrow to work on rehab and prehab for my knee and my shoulders.
 
5/6/15 - Friday

Bench and OHP. Did a lot of hip mobility and did some squats and overhead squats (yes, I actually managed them!) before hand. As well as some straight legged muscle snatches and Klokov press as warmups.

Bench

Bar x lots
40kg x 8
50kg x 2x4
60kg x 2x2
65kg x 9 - rep pb!

Last rep was wibbly wobbly and even the eight was a tad scetchy as it just about touched my chest, but I'm happy and counting them all as I initially started out with fully controlled and properly paused.

OHP

Bar x 8
27.5kg x 6
32.5kg x 3
37.5kg x 3x1 - Flew up
35kg x 3x5 - Much, much easier than I expected

Pleasantly surprised since the 32.5kg warmup felt a tad iffy but all of the working sets were brilliant.

Happy with that. Rest for now and shall deadlift tomorrow :D
 
6/6/15 - Saturday

16 sets of deadlifts in 54 minutes. Go!

Deficit Deadlifts 3"

60kg x 5
75kg x 3
90kg x 2x3
97.5kg x 4x3

Deadlift Block Pulls 3"

105kg x 2x4
120kg(B) x 2x4
127.5kg(B,S) x 4x4

It turns out I like deficit deadlifts, I like them a lot. They do however knacker you out when you want to go and do anything else.
Block pulls in generally were brilliant but the last 4 working sets were exhausting and straps were used. I may have been able to do it without straps but I didn't have the time to find out.
 
9/6/15 - Tuesday (Monday)

Dedlifts, bench, and then more deadlifts.

Deadlift 3" deficit

70kg x 4
90kg x 2x3
105kg x 5x2

I recorded my sets and noticed that in my firsts my head pulled back, I corrected that quickly enough.

Bench

Bar x lots
40kg x 8
50kg x 8
60kg x 3
67.5kg x 3x2
57.5kg x 3x5

Back was worn out already so I lost tightness on two of the 3 67.5kg sets. Once again it was corrected with a tighter setup.

OHP

Bar x lots
25kg x 6
30kg x 3
35kg x 8

Too worn out to get any more reps at 35kg.

Deadlifts

70kg x 5
92.5kg x 5
105kg x 5
120kg (B) x 5

Well I'm knackered. 120kg felt heavier than it should have but went up easy enough. Really felt it in my glutes which is new to me, maybe they're actually doing something now.
Rest and pizza tonight for more training tomorrow. Maybe squats; definitely bench.
 
Last edited:
16/06/15 - Tuesday

Bench and OHP. It feels good to be back after an unintended week off.

Bench

Bar x lots
40kg x 8
50kg x 2x4
57.5kg x 3
62.5kg x 5x5

Heavier than they should but still easy, not lightning quick but still easy.

OHP

Bar x lots
27.5kg x 6
35kg x 8
32.5kg x 8
30kg x 10

Having to use a slightly wider grip to use more shoulder than just tricep. feels nicer on the elbow and overall feels about the same in terms of strength.

Nice shot and easy session. Bajillions of deadlifts tomorrow.
 
17/6/15 - Wednesday

D-D-D-D-D-D-Deadliftssssss

Deficit Deadlifts 3"

60kg x 5
80kg x 3
95kg x 2x3
102.5kg x 4x2

Miles better than last time, straighter back and better pulls.

Deadlift

105kg x 5
120kg(B) x 3
135kg(B) x 5 - Rep PB!

Really happy with that, that puts my project max higher than what my actual max is but we'll find out more about that when it comes to it. Hopefully not for a long time as I have no intentions on maxing atm until November.

Back extensions 90

BW x 2x20

Back extensions

Bar x 2x12

I've missed these.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom