Why do we need data to support theory 2? It's a statement of a belief supported by faith. It falls within the remit of religion, not science, so the data you desperately seek is not needed by those that believe it.
They may not need data to support it, but if they wish to inhabit the same reality as everyone else and try to teach others that the universe was, indeed, created in six days, had they not better provide better evidence than "It's part of my faith?"
Whilst it may be what Christians believe, for them to try and tell others that it is the way things are is a blatant un-truth.