OK
Next thing I'd try is another make/model type of drive, do you know anybody who has them in cupboards (like me)?
And yes you can have 3 borked drives in a row.
Earlier this year I had 3x eBike batteries that were all duff.
yes i have others drives here and they can be hot swapped into the icy cages
got a friend coming over later with his desktop to see if he has the same issue with the drive too