How do you think it should be taught then? I don't know you can have a rant about it without any solutions on how to solve this "problem".
Also talking about people to physics, I have not known anyone who has got a good grade in the first module who were not doing maths. Even though maths A level is not necessary for physics, it sure does how keep your maths skills up to scratch and like 70% involve maths.
Also I don't know about you but most of maths teaching up to year 9 was fairly interactive, we did not sit in classes all day solving problems. I remember when our teacher took us out onto the netball court and we had to find the value of PI.
I suppose there are two things I'd like to see. A bit more care in defining structures and functions considered in school mathematics, and logic being taught as early as possible. Rigorously defining functions like sin, cosine and tangent at GCSE is stupid and unhelpful, but it would be a start to actually define them in some useful sense before asking students to use them as I've seen happen. With regard to logic, you don't have to build up mathematics from scratch, but actually giving students an idea of what logic actually is in terms of mathematical results I think is almost fundamental to encouraging creative thinking in the subject.
Is it helpful for an A-Level student to learn what a limit is before starting calculus? If they're going on to university Mathematics/Physics maybe, but for anything else of course not! But it's a shame that someone coming out of school onto a mathematics course has to effectively relearn almost everything they studied at A-Level.
Do I think school maths is totally symptomatic of 'broken education garrrr!'? No, of course not. There's a lot of good stuff in there, but from what I personally have seen from being in the system myself and tutoring students in the system now, there are certainly improvements that could be made. Most importantly, do I think that mine is the be-all and end-all of opinions? Of course not, but I'd certainly like to engage in discussion about how the system can be improved
.It's great and I wouldnt discourage for a second that teachers make the effort to engage the students with what they need to know, but finding the value of Pi to some arbitrary degree of rational accuracy isnt making you think. It's a clever and interesting way of helping students to remember the relationship between the radius and circumference of a circle.
Last edited: