• Notice regarding image hosts and attachments. See here.

Vista or XP

Those network issues have been the subject of many threads. I've never had any, and technically XP should work fine - but turning the level of authentication required down seems to help some:

http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showthread.php?t=17688267
http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showthread.php?t=17691472
http://forums.overclockers.co.uk/showthread.php?t=17686340

First option, though: You may need NetBIOS over TCP/IP. This is probably why I don't have problems - I use DNS:

1. right click the Network icon in the Notification Area
2. click Network and Sharing Center
3. click Manage network connections
4. make sure that Network Discovery is On (note - in a Windows Domain, this may need to be enabled by an administrator using a GPO)
5. make sure that File Sharing is On
6. make sure that Public folder sharing is Off
7. if you have a printer locally installed that you want other computers to use, make sure Printer Sharing is On
8. click Manage network connections (left pane)
9. right click the Local Area Connection (or whatever network connection is in use - e.g. a wireless connection)
10. select Properties
11. click Continue in the UAC prompt (or supply Administrative username and password)
12. select Internet Protocol Version 4 (TCP/IPv4)
13. click Properties
14. click Advanced...
14. select the WINS tab
15. select the Enable NetBIOS over TCP/IP radio button
16. click OK; click OK; click Close - this change will take affect immediately - no need to logoff or restart
 
Last edited:
if people don't like vista don't use it.... simple as that. don't say "oh vista crap, it isn't as good xp" if u don't like it, just go back to xp... microsoft isn't saying u must upgrade...

for me vista runs great without any problems
 
Last edited:
Been the first time in a while that I haven't rushed out to get the new version. Still happy with XP at the mo, seems to be best to wait for SP1 at least before moving on these days.
 
Vista > XP

I used XP Pro and went to Vista Ultimate and haven't regretted it one bit.

Better support for DVD from the beginning, looks better, faster and more responsive, media centre fantastic, I just love it on so many levels.

This seems good to me, as it's so new and can only get better.
 
|Ric| said:
I think more importantly is asking the question why you get Office with MSDNAA?!
Indeed. I've seen many people claim this but the reality is that Microsoft says Office is the only product a student should be buying - with their own money!
 
djjuk said:
Been the first time in a while that I haven't rushed out to get the new version. Still happy with XP at the mo, seems to be best to wait for SP1 at least before moving on these days.

Same here. I got Win2kpro, WindMill, and WinXP as soon as they came out. I've not really seen any reason to move to Vista as yet as XP seems very good to me for most things - first version of windows I've not had any major gripes with really.

Sure it would be nice to check out Vista, but I would want to buy a retail rather than OEM version in case I do hardware upgrades etc and at the moment I don't really wanna shell out $$$ for something which may end up giving me problems.
 
csmager said:
Vista will clean install in 20-25mins. Try it - if it doesn't work well enough (can't find all the drivers), then put XP on. I think you'll be pleasantly surprised though - unless you have some obscure hardware.

I've been reading up the past few days whether or not to install it, in the end I just went for it and touch wood everything went perfectly well. The only thing that I haven't got working is the PS2 Eye Toy i use for my webcam!
 
gareth170 said:
microsoft isn't saying u must upgrade...


Err... Yes they are.

MS are pushing like hell to force OEMs to install Vista only and not XP.

MS are not going to support businesses anymore that are using XP, only Vista.

XP support which was supposed to be going on till 2009 dropped off rapidly with Vista or rather longhorn development and now its pretty much being stopped a lot sooner... I have read in a few places that XP support is being stopped this year, although how reliable that is I dont know, but going by the way MS are avoiding XP in other areas, this comes as no surprise at all.

Then again....

http://blogs.zdnet.com/Bott/?p=133
 
Last edited:
FatRakoon said:
Err... Yes they are.

MS are pushing like hell to force OEMs to install Vista only and not XP.

MS are not going to support businesses anymore that are using XP, only Vista.

XP support which was supposed to be going on till 2009 dropped off rapidly with Vista or rather longhorn development and now its pretty much being stopped a lot sooner... I have read in a few places that XP support is being stopped this year, although how reliable that is I dont know, but going by the way MS are avoiding XP in other areas, this comes as no surprise at all.

http://support.microsoft.com/lifecycle/?p1=3223

Code:
Products Released	Windows XP Professional
General Availability Date 31/12/2001
Mainstream Support Retired [B]14/04/2009	[/B]
Extended Support Retired [B]08/04/2014[/B]
 
I remember this exact same thing with people moving to XP. . . Everytime microsoft brings out a new OS, people immediately slate it. Personally, i quite like Vista, driver support for 64-bit is very very poor, but it can only get better, and at the end of the day, that ISNT microsofts fault. Its the fault of the manufacturers. I am dual booting with XP because im quite happy with XP and use vista when i feel like it.
Some people just dont like change. They feel uncomfortable with Vista and so immediately give it bad press. Its the same for a lot of things.

One thing i like about vista, it actually runs the buggiest game ever. BF2142. Ive never tried any others. But i can finally play this game on Vista and i was completely unable to on XP. Even though when i went to install it it said "This game is only tested on XP 32-bit".

I would recommend that people use XP until the first service pack, but only because the driver support is poor. Things will work, but not to the best they can.
 
FatRakoon said:
Err... Yes they are.

MS are pushing like hell to force OEMs to install Vista only and not XP.

MS are not going to support businesses anymore that are using XP, only Vista.

XP support which was supposed to be going on till 2009 dropped off rapidly with Vista or rather longhorn development and now its pretty much being stopped a lot sooner... I have read in a few places that XP support is being stopped this year, although how reliable that is I dont know, but going by the way MS are avoiding XP in other areas, this comes as no surprise at all.

Then again....

http://blogs.zdnet.com/Bott/?p=133

i didn't mean businesses.. what i meant was the home users who have xp and vista. if the home user don't like vista don't use it.... simple as that. just go back to xp...

as for businesses we've known MS was gonna stop xp support for businesses sooner then later.. theres no point being angry about it
 
FatRakoon said:
Err... Yes they are.

MS are pushing like hell to force OEMs to install Vista only and not XP.

MS are not going to support businesses anymore that are using XP, only Vista.

XP support which was supposed to be going on till 2009 dropped off rapidly with Vista or rather longhorn development and now its pretty much being stopped a lot sooner... I have read in a few places that XP support is being stopped this year, although how reliable that is I dont know, but going by the way MS are avoiding XP in other areas, this comes as no surprise at all.
So even if half of that was true... it's still no worse than any of Microsoft competitors? :D
 
PhillyDee said:
I remember this exact same thing with people moving to XP. . . Everytime microsoft brings out a new OS, people immediately slate it. Personally, i quite like Vista, driver support for 64-bit is very very poor, but it can only get better, and at the end of the day, that ISNT microsofts fault. Its the fault of the manufacturers. I am dual booting with XP because im quite happy with XP and use vista when i feel like it.
Some people just dont like change. They feel uncomfortable with Vista and so immediately give it bad press. Its the same for a lot of things.

i agree with u totaly... people don't give a new OS a chance, they just shuddery think its crap if a program or driver doesn't work... to me personly vista is better then xp and vista is faster...
 
Last edited:
I have tried to give it a chance... I really have.

I have bought a copy, and I have put it onto 4 different PCs so far, never got as far as activating it "JUST IN CASE" which was just as well, because it has never run at all well on any of them.

I currently have it on a PC once again, and once again, I am unable to do half of the most basic things without something going silly or hanging, or generally just ignoring me completely.

I am also so fed up with it asking me all the time to confirm that the button I clicked was indeed the one I should have done... I clicked it didnt I???

There is so many things about Vista that annoy me.

The thign is, that if you have only used Windows as your O/S then Vista will look like a great next option in your computing choices, and sure, thats great, but if you have used other stuff, such as LNX/MAC and hell, even Amiga/Atari then you will see that Vista really just looks like XP with a lot of stolen code bolted on.

I like the look of Vista. I really do, and had it run right on my PCs then I would certainly have gone with it, but unfortunately, it does not. Games are disgusting on it, even the ones that are VISTA compatible, Internet access is very much crippled for me, although I cannot figure out why, and nothing I do will let me copy files across my network either to or from the Vista PC, even though I can happily go in and out of any folder on any PC from any other PC, including the Vista PC, attempting to copy files only hangs explorer??? so no, I will not be using vista just yet.

Sure, once we see an SP for it, and I feel that it will be sooner rather than later judging by the massive number of issues vista is having, then sure, I will re-try it. Not yet though.

I also think MS rushed it out too quickly, I really do.

And also having a 32bit and a 64Bit versions of Basic, Business, Premuim, and Ultimate, has only made things very confusing... Even for those who know the difference, its still a very awkward thing for MS to have done I recon.

MS promised us from day 1 that the 32Bit and 64Bit versions will be 100% compatible across the board, especially with drivers... This is still turning out to be yet another MS lie. Vista 64 doesnt even have anywhere near half the support of 32Bit.
 
FatRakoon said:
Err... Yes they are.

MS are pushing like hell to force OEMs to install Vista only and not XP.
No quicker than they withdrew Windows 98/2000 when XP came out. Nothing they're doing is unusual.

MS are not going to support businesses anymore that are using XP, only Vista.
I doubt that - if they're carrying on mainstream support till 2009 & extended till 2014, it's unlikely they'll exclude business. Not forgetting most businesses are still running Windows 2000, as there was little reason to justify an upgrade to XP.
 
gareth170 said:
if people don't like vista don't use it.... simple as that. don't say "oh vista crap, it isn't as good xp" if u don't like it, just go back to xp... microsoft isn't saying u must upgrade...

Come on Gareth, just because you don't happen to agree with the viewpoint that "Vista is crap" doesn't mean that people shouldn't be allowed to say it or have to go silently go back to XP.

Whilst your quite vocal in your opinion for Vista I feel you should allow others to be the same, even if you don't agree with their opinion. This is after all a discussion forum about XP vs Vista.

MS makes money by people upgrading to the latest and greatest, so its hardly likely to say "you don't have to upgrade" is it? I imagine that all the money MS has spent on marketing Vista is their way of saying "you must upgrade". And as of next year MS are stopping selling XP all together, so what choice do you have then?
 
FatRakoon said:
MS are pushing like hell to force OEMs to install Vista only and not XP.
You use emotive language to make it sound as if MS are doing something "evil" or underhand here. It's simply normal business, MS will only supply their current OS going forward in exactly the same way as every other producer does. You can't wander into a Ford dealer and demand they supply you a brand new Mk3 Escort either.

FatRakoon said:
MS are not going to support businesses anymore that are using XP, only Vista.
Not true, XP is supported until at least 2014 for both XP pro and Home edition.

FatRakoon said:
XP support which was supposed to be going on till 2009 dropped off rapidly with Vista or rather longhorn development and now its pretty much being stopped a lot sooner... I have read in a few places that XP support is being stopped this year, although how reliable that is I dont know, but going by the way MS are avoiding XP in other areas, this comes as no surprise at all.
Again totaly untrue.

FatRakoon said:
It really easy to check this kind of stuff. www.microsoft.com/lifecycle.

FatRakoon said:
Vista really just looks like XP with a lot of stolen code bolted on.
Which code is this exactly?

Not having a go at you FatRakoon but this is the kind of stuff that the boards here are clogged with everytime anyone says the word "Vista". It's just a product, a newer version of an OS. It's not a life style choice or of critical imporance to the quality of peoples lives.

It's new, it has some challenges (particularly around drivers), it's bound to have some compatability problems with some older software designed for an entirely different OS.

Let's move on eh and stop rehashing the same ol same ol. Every attempt at any kind of productive thread to help out people playing with Vista get's invaded by "MS are the dbil" "Vista is crap, if you use it you are an idiot" posts.

Sure it's a forum, it just seems a little pointless and confrontational for the sake of it... /shrug.
 
Last edited:
Dual boot if you play games. I run a stripped to the core version of XP (install disc came in at about 180mb) which I run all my games (save UT) in, and vista for day to day work
 
the-void said:
MS makes money by people upgrading to the latest and greatest, so its hardly likely to say "you don't have to upgrade" is it? I imagine that all the money MS has spent on marketing Vista is their way of saying "you must upgrade". And as of next year MS are stopping selling XP all together, so what choice do you have then?
You don't have to upgrade at all. You have your copy of XP and can continue to use it forever should you so choose. Of course MS is stopping selling XP next year, why would they continue to sell an old product for more than a year after it's been replaced by a new one. Can you still specify System 7 on a new Mac? Brand new Sierra from a Ford dealer? Time and technology changes and moves on, it's not an evil conspiricy... Honest...
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom