Whaley Bridge (UK) - attempted burglary / shooting

Man of Honour
Joined
24 Sep 2005
Posts
35,549
Just because he's out burgling doesn't mean he deserved death. Maybe he was being forced into it himself by some horrid pimp-like gangster, you really never know.

The lack of police action is no doubt incentivising crime at the moment though. My friend got knocked off his bike, hit and run, with several witnesses verifying the number plate and the appearance of the driver... and apparently the police still didn't do anything?!
 
Last edited:
Caporegime
Joined
8 Jan 2004
Posts
32,100
Location
Rutland
Just because he's out burgling doesn't mean he deserved death. Maybe he was being forced into it himself by some horrid pimp-like gangster, you really never know.

The lack of police action is no doubt incentivising crime at the moment though. My friend got knocked off his bike, hit and run, with several witnesses verifying the number plate and the appearance of the driver... and apparently the police still didn't do anything?!
Tough one, outnumbered atleast 2:1 if not 4:1 potentially and in a remote location. It'll boil down to if he felt personally threatened of harm, which seems pretty reasonable.
 
Man of Honour
Joined
24 Sep 2005
Posts
35,549
Tough one, outnumbered atleast 2:1 if not 4:1 potentially and in a remote location. It'll boil down to if he felt personally threatened of harm, which seems pretty reasonable.

In respect of ‘was the shooter acting reasonably in firing the weapon as he did?’ - yes, it depends as you say.

This is a different point to the one I was making, which was more along the lines of ‘he did not necessary deserve death’.

I said this in light of the sentiments in the thread re: the deceased getting what he deserved. Even if the shooter gets off free and acted reasonably, it still doesn’t mean the deceased deserved death. It could be a wholly tragic set-up.
 
Soldato
Joined
29 Jul 2004
Posts
7,053
Deserved what he got if he was breaking into homes and robbing, ruining others lives without a second thought.

Niteflys response is exactly why the nation is so limp wristed on crime.

Net positive for society that he's no longer alive.
 
Commissario
Joined
17 Oct 2002
Posts
33,053
Location
Panting like a fiend
What law does apply to this. Genuine question, I don’t know, not trying to catch you out.
Basically you can use any "reasonable" level of force to protect yourself and family.
Reasonable meaning what could be considered reasonable in the moment, which basically means as long as you don't lay in wait, set traps, use illegal weapons, or beat someone when they're no longer a threat (IE already down and unconsciouse, shoot them in the back, chase them down the street, tie them up and torture them) you're pretty much fine. The Police will investigate if there is serious injury or death, and may arrest you to ensure your rights are covered (you are entitled to a free solicitor etc and it restrains what they can do), but basically if your house is broken into you have to go massively over the top for any charges to be brought, and even further over the top for a jury (remember they are 12 people like you) to even consider finding you guilty.

As I say, as long as you don't set out to kill someone, but happen to grab a knife in the kitchen, golf clubs, the hammer you've been using for decorating, the cricket bat next to the sporting cloths, a harpoon from the cupboard next to you where your scuba gear is stored you're basically ok (these are btw all real instances).

IIRC it's not so much a specific "law" as written down by the government, but rather largely case law over the last few hundred years where courts have defined what is likely reasonable etc.
 
Soldato
OP
Joined
3 Aug 2015
Posts
7,323
IIRC it's not so much a specific "law" as written down by the government, but rather largely case law over the last few hundred years where courts have defined what is likely reasonable etc.
Ah right, understood. Would be nice to have a black letter law on this but not really a top priority.
 
Commissario
Joined
17 Oct 2002
Posts
33,053
Location
Panting like a fiend
Ah right, understood. Would be nice to have a black letter law on this but not really a top priority.
IIRC the government did something a few years back as a bit of a performative legislations where they said they'd put it in law that people had a right to defend themselves etc. But the right has been enshrined in common and case law literally for centuries, with the odd example case going to the court if it's a new "extreme" variation*.

From what I remember pretty much everyone who'd ever paid attention to the laws/rules on self defence and the Police/CPS guidelines went "that's what we've already got you opportunistic bunch of muppets" along with mutterings along the likes of "and to think you claim you have a law degree" at several of the government members who were desperately trying to make out this was something entirely new.


*The CPS put cases forward where either there is a good chance of success, or where there is a public interest element, so they might put a case forward to ensure the full facts are on the public record even if the chance of the prosecution being successful are much lower than normal.
 
Last edited:
Man of Honour
Joined
24 Sep 2005
Posts
35,549
What's so hard to understand?

You claiming that it’s a “Net positive for society that he's no longer alive.whilst simultaneously acknowledging that you don’t know actually what happened (hence “if”).

It’s either very callous, for being glad that someone is dead without knowing the circumstances, or really stupid. Either way it’s a royal herp-derp.
 
Soldato
Joined
29 Jul 2004
Posts
7,053
You claiming that it’s a “Net positive for society that he's no longer alive.whilst simultaneously acknowledging that you don’t know actually what happened (hence “if”).

It’s either very callous, for being glad that someone is dead without knowing the circumstances, or really stupid. Either way it’s a royal herp-derp.
So you don't understand the meaning of the word If.
 
Man of Honour
Joined
24 Sep 2005
Posts
35,549
So you don't understand the meaning of the word If.

If you said “if he was breaking into homes and robbing, ruining others lives without a second thought, then it’s a net positive for society that he's no longer alive.” then that would have been different.

But that wasn’t what you wrote. There was no “if” in the final sentence of your post.

I can only respond to the words that you write. If you actually didn’t mean this absolutely:

Net positive for society that he's no longer alive.

… then going forwards you ought to take more care to be precise over your choice of words / how you structure your posts, so that people can more readily understand what you intend to mean.
 
Last edited:
Soldato
Joined
21 Jan 2010
Posts
22,579
If you said “if he was breaking into homes and robbing, ruining others lives without a second thought, then it’s a net positive for society that he's no longer alive.” then that would have been different.

But that wasn’t what you wrote. There was no “if” in the final sentence of your post.

I can only respond to the words that you write. If you actually didn’t mean this absolutely:



… then going forwards you ought to take more care to be precise over your choice of words / how you structure your posts, so that people can more readily understand what you intend to mean.
Grow up man its a computer forum
 
Man of Honour
Joined
24 Sep 2005
Posts
35,549
Grow up man its a computer forum

Wut?! You can grow up / learn to read / learn to think if you regard that I’m the person being unreasonable in that exchange!

There’s no reason to drag it on though so with that I’m out / onwards for the thread.
 
Soldato
Joined
15 Oct 2003
Posts
14,825
Location
Chengdu
Just a shame he didn't get the others too.
Zero sympathy for the dead here. They put themselves in to the situation. A lot of sympathy for the victims of the burglary, no doubt a large amount of nonsense for them to go through for the rest of the year.

Police seem pretty useless in the UK these days.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom