Which electric screwdriver (not drills)

ShiWarrior · 28 Apr 2024 at 09:16

I could do with an electric screwdriver, it wont be used very often, and i certainly don't want a drill. i don't do any DIY hardly so pointless getting a drill

i looked at this

https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0BCH4RR13/?coliid=IXYZV7XN0IXOC&colid=15FRFL8T36IHR&psc=1&ref_=list_c_wl_lv_ov_lig_dp_it

without the set, then i noticed they do an "off set" attachment for an extra £20
so the set would the one to go for

but then there is this one at around same price that reviews seem to suggest its better than the above ?

https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B07FTVR5H2?tag=experevi-21&linkCode=ogi&th=1&ascsubtag=1412450

can some one help my decision please as I'm no expert and don't venture into Home and garden

thanks

dlockers · 28 Apr 2024 at 09:39

I had the little small Bosch thing for ages, only recently binned it (it was like 12 years old). Works fine but quite limited use. Id probably get the Bosch mini thing that pops up on hukd now.

This:

Bosch Professional 12V Cordless Combi Drill GSB 120-LI at Amazon, £57.49 | hotukdeals

www.hotukdeals.com

DXP55 · 28 Apr 2024 at 09:52

I was in B&Q the other week and they had some battery screwdrivers - One that took my eye was a cheapo (12 quid) 7v I think and like the pistol Bosch but you press a button and twist it and it becomes like second Bosch on your list,
I have a Worx pistol one I bought years ago when Homebase closed a lot of it's stores for £5 -It has come in very handy at times.

Wow I see they are £40 plus now - Mine has the bits stored in top and you just pull top back -turn holder round to the bit you want then shut it up.

Reuben klang · 28 Apr 2024 at 10:04

dlockers said:
I had the little small Bosch thing for ages, only recently binned it (it was like 12 years old). Works fine but quite limited use. Id probably get the Bosch mini thing that pops up on hukd now.

This:

Bosch Professional 12V Cordless Combi Drill GSB 120-LI at Amazon, £57.49 | hotukdeals

www.hotukdeals.com

I second this I still have mine it’s over >15 years still going strong.

ShiWarrior · 28 Apr 2024 at 10:08

dlockers said:
I had the little small Bosch thing for ages, only recently binned it (it was like 12 years old). Works fine but quite limited use. Id probably get the Bosch mini thing that pops up on hukd now.

This:

Bosch Professional 12V Cordless Combi Drill GSB 120-LI at Amazon, £57.49 | hotukdeals

www.hotukdeals.com

Thanks
i have a feeling the torque would be too much for tiny jobs (like flat pack furniture from ikea, and adjusting the shelves when required) etc

FlyingFish · 28 Apr 2024 at 10:33

If you can afford to push the boat out then go for this Makita.

Screwdriver

I used to have one of those Bosch electric drivers, but most of the time it wasn't man enough for the jobs I needed, it couldn't even remove hand tight fixings. That's when I started looking into something with a bit more torque. The Makita runs from zero to full speed with fantastic control in both directions whether you're left or right handed, the trigger mounted on the barrel gives perfect operation, and the handle can pivot into a gun configuration if needed. 2x batteries and the charger make for a great kit.

This is the impact version which means it can help with really stubborn screws, highly recommended over the standard screwdriver version.

ChrisD. · 28 Apr 2024 at 10:36

I have this for small jobs and I find it excellent.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B00XI610R0

Edit - I have the 5th gen (linked), they do a 6th and 7th as well.

bazzabear · 28 Apr 2024 at 10:46

One thing I would say for a screwdriver - make sure that it has a variable speed trigger.

I was an early adopter when Bosch started doing the mini ones, but the first model was either on or off, and it was a pain to be honest not having that fine control. Especially when you were trying to deal with a screw whose head was already a bit battered and not wanting to damage it more.

ShiWarrior · 28 Apr 2024 at 11:13

FlyingFish said:
If you can afford to push the boat out then go for this Makita.

Screwdriver

I used to have one of those Bosch electric drivers, but most of the time it wasn't man enough for the jobs I needed, it couldn't even remove hand tight fixings. That's when I started looking into something with a bit more torque. The Makita runs from zero to full speed with fantastic control in both directions whether you're left or right handed, the trigger mounted on the barrel gives perfect operation, and the handle can pivot into a gun configuration if needed. 2x batteries and the charger make for a great kit.

This is the impact version which means it can help with really stubborn screws, highly recommended over the standard screwdriver version.

thanks

cost far too much for me though especially as i won't use it much
looks good though

ShiWarrior · 29 Apr 2024 at 12:39

ChrisD. said:
I have this for small jobs and I find it excellent.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B00XI610R0

Edit - I have the 5th gen (linked), they do a 6th and 7th as well.

I thought the one I linked to was the 7th gen ?

pepp77 · 29 Apr 2024 at 12:43

I have the little Bosch screwdriver as well with the Torque attachment. Been a godsend when trying to install switches into racks on my own.

ChrisD. · 29 Apr 2024 at 12:46

ShiWarrior said:
I thought the one I linked to was the 7th gen ?

I didn't even see you linked one in your post! I have it (5th gen), I also have a Bosch Professional combi, a few other combi's and an impact driver, and I used the Bosch screwdriver for small house jobs and my wife uses it when she's doing bits and bobs. It's still going strong after 6+ years and a house move.

ShiWarrior · 29 Apr 2024 at 12:49

pepp77 said:
I have the little Bosch screwdriver as well with the Torque attachment. Been a godsend when trying to install switches into racks on my own.

The pistol grip one or the other one?

dirtychinchilla · 29 Apr 2024 at 12:52

We use the Bosch ones at work in the warehouse for all sorts and they're pretty bulletproof.

pepp77 · 29 Apr 2024 at 14:27

ShiWarrior said:
The pistol grip one or the other one?

Same as first one OP linked to, pistol grip one.

Didn't know they had a straight one. Prefer the pistol grip style as they allow pressure to be applied better when required.

ShiWarrior · 29 Apr 2024 at 15:35

pepp77 said:
Same as first one OP linked to, pistol grip one.

Didn't know they had a straight one. Prefer the pistol grip style as they allow pressure to be applied better when required.

Thanks
I'm the OP and I linked to both styles

Martynt74 · 29 Apr 2024 at 15:40

Pistol grip Bosch one would be my preference too. Mine is still working after around 10yrs. Although i usually just use my impact driver these days, it's easy to limit the torque

pepp77 · 29 Apr 2024 at 15:45

ShiWarrior said:
Thanks
I'm the OP and I linked to both styles

yeah, i paid attention to about 60%, only saw the link to the pistol grip one in the OP and then didnt look at who quoted me lol

Countcussy · 29 Apr 2024 at 15:47

I Have a Worx one, that has stood up to allsorts of abuse. It also comes with a hex pilot drill which is one of those items that you do not know you need, until you have it.

https://www.toolstation.com/worx-4v-slide-driver/p42502

I got it for much cheaper than that, when it was on offer somewhere.

Plus, I can pretend I`m a badass whilst changing bits :cry:

mattyfez · 29 Apr 2024 at 16:10

I'd honestly just get a battery powered combi drill.
The chucks have a torque dial so you can set the torque so low you can even stop it by grabbing it with your hand if you want to.

A much more versatile tool.
Something like this for example

Bosch 18V 1 x 2Ah Li-ion Cordless Combi drill EasyImpact 18V-40 | DIY at B&Q

Effortless and flexible screwdriving, drilling, or impact drilling. This cordless EasyImpact 18V-40 combi drill is the flexible all-rounder for an array of drilling and fastening jobs.

www.diy.com