But what really narked me is that the fourth quote down is from Hastings Direct themselves for £86 for exactly the same policy underwritten by exactly the same people.
Had exactly the same problem with Hastings last year. I cancelled my policy over the phone and started a new one from the insurance comparison site.
This is something that should be stamped on though, it annoys the crap out of me that these companies lie as a matter of course to customers to attempt to extort more money from them.