Whilst not commenting on the specifics of Salary sacrifice schemes, generally if you are entitled to a car allowance then unless if you are doing a high mileage (15K+) then Personal Leasing can offer some amazing cars, especially if you are prepared to be flexible on colour model for their special “stock” deals.
Owning a car, especially one that is expensive and outside of its manufacturer warranty can be a risky game. Also purchasing used generally means either paying extortionate interest rates, usually 6.9%-10.9% APR, whilst a Personal Loan offers cheaper rates for those with good credit you can end up with multiple loans for a car that’s £20K+.
Another factor as well as is that PCP deals for new cars are not so tied into your credit score, so they take people that would often get rejected for a low APR personal loan. With a PCP you are responsible for servicing, tyres, road tax (£310 surcharge on cars with a list price of over £40K registered after April 2017 for first five years), but you don’t have the depreciation risk of what the car is going to be worth at the end.
Personal leasing includes the Road Tax and you can opt for a maintenance package covering servicing, tyres, and even in some cases an extended warranty.
These days cars have become more of a utility, it’s just a monthly expense, so to me personal leasing or PCP schemes can offer great value for money, just watch the interest rate on PCP deals on expensive cars, since you are not repaying the whole amount the interest soon adds up.
I am driving a 67 plate BMW 520d M Sport that lists at over £53K on a PCP at 1.9% APR for £450 a month over 4 years with a £4K deposit, since it is loaded with optional extras a PCP worked out cheaper as negotiated a £10K+ discount, with a further £4K deposit contribution from BMW and included in the costs is the Servicing Pack for five years.