As I’ve said a few times, absolutely people are working on weapons programs. Non have been described in this thread though. The congressional hearings certainly didn’t. Its use of or belief in outrageous claims that’s an issue for me.
Pentagon releases UFO footage
- Thread starter Doobedoo
- Start date
As I’ve said a few times, absolutely people are working on weapons programs. Non have been described in this thread though. The congressional hearings certainly didn’t. Its use of or belief in outrageous claims that’s an issue for me.
Soldato
Ah right ok. So what’s been debunked? That it’s aliens?
My main gripe with the thing, was the inconsistency in the argument.
On the one hand - it was argued that David Grusch is legit and his testimony is “beyond reproach” etc,
But David Grusch definitely claimed that it’s aliens.
The resulting position is resolved to simply cherry picking the bits from that testimony, but disregarding the rest.
Ergo - the whole argument was inconsistent and confusing.
You’re going to be need to be more specific, but yes for most of the claims. As I said a few times before, unless we add elements of supernatural variety and reject all other plausible explanations we’re down to old fashioned faith.
Last edited:
Soldato
Forgive me, I’ve not actually seen Grusch state specifically it’s aliens. Can you post a quote/link?
I know he’s said some daft things but I’ve genuinely not seen him make that claim.
He did.
Soldato
What do I need to be more specific about - I asked what had been debunked and gave the aliens line as one possible example.
But that being said you’ll have to link me to where pottsey claimed it was aliens because as far as I can tell he’s been pretty vocal that he doesn’t believe it’s aliens.
Soldato
Ok cool. But you’ll have to provide evidence - which should be easy enough I’d imagine. As I’ve not actually seen Grusch claim that - not saying he hasn’t just that I haven’t seen that.
Its aliens is about all that remains. Or possibly God, fairies insert whatever.
Already done. Several times. Look harder, the truth is out there.
Soldato
No no. You can’t do that, you’ve said that Grusch specifically stated it was aliens and I’m asking you for proof of that. Not what you think it might/might not be.
Man of Honour
I supplied evidence and Pottsey accepted it but no idea where the videos have gone
Last edited:
Soldato
Nope, screech made the claim. You’ve backed it up. Provide evidence please.
Yes yes I can.
Soldato
So you’re not prepared to provide evidence for your claims?
I’m not rewatching interviews with crazy claims for your curiosity.
Soldato
Surely it can’t be that hard to grab some evidence of your claim? I mean it pretty much renders your claim baseless if you can’t. I’ve watch a few clips of some of his interviews and I’ve genuinely not seen him say ‘it’s aliens’ - again I’m not saying he hasn’t but it’d be nice for the purposes of fair debate that you back your claim up.
Ultimately though, even if he has, so what? While it might make him appear a bigger crank than most already think he is it’s the evidence that’s important not his opinion.
Soldato
Probably too much and not enough! Too much money spent and not enough answers. We need those with the evidence, whatever that may be, to do whatever’s needed to prove or disprove it’s authenticity.
Lol, not sure if serious.