That does look a good team on paper.Your back four were Finnan, Carragher, Hyypia, Riise... full of experience and ability.
Xabi Alonso, Lucas, Banayoun and Babel in midfield... okay some young talent there, but all on paper better than anything Barnsley should have been able to offer.
Kuyt and Crouch up front - both of whom should have been good enough to finish off Barnsley.
Steve McClaren had a good England team on paper and couldn't get anything out of them. He lost his job.