Why not phone AOL up, tell them you've been a loyal customer for several years and that your leaving them because there are now detter deals that make their service look like a total waste of money. Maybe they'll make some sort of offer. Failing that, cancel and join one of the many recommended ISPs above.
I gave AOL a call last night and told them i want to cancel. She asked who i wanted to move to and i said BE, their 24meg package (just to make AOLs sound extremely pathetic at 2meg lol)
[AOL] Well i can tell you now, you will get nowhere near that speed sir, BT can give you a much more accura
[Me] (interupts) I already know that but according to BT i can get around 13meg.
*goes quiet for a few seconds*
[AOL] Well what we can do is, i can request to put you up to 8meg because at the moment your on a 1meg package...
[Me] Im on 1meg atm?
[AOL] yes, thats right...
[Me] Well i download at 2.5
[AOL] Thats just an estimate
[Me] ... no, i actually download things at 2.5
[AOL] yeah, thats just as estimate from BT
[Me] no you dont understand, my literal download speed right now, through you... is 2.5
*few seconds silence*
[AOL] Well i can request to put you up to 8meg AND only charge you £6.99 a month instead of £14.99
Then she started going on about some bull**** about the speed can only be raised in areas at a time, so unless other AOL customers in my area request a higher speed, then i will have to wait. Basically it just seemed like a lower bill with the promise of 8meg that will never be a reality. So i just said, no thankyou id like to switch.
Then i asked if i can keep my e-mail accounts that i have with AOL because, like, i need them. AOL do a free e-mail service to anyone just like hotmail and ive googled the situation and people say yes, just ask to have your e-mail switched to their free e-mail service. I asked and she said no we cant do that.
I rung back and spoke to a different person in the general helpline and he didnt even ask for my account name or anything, he just said.
The emails are free sir, you can cancel and they will be yours, you dont need to do anything about it!
Really?
Yes, they are completely free and they wont be deleted.
Just shows how much the salespeople lie to try and dissuade you from leaving them

So anyway, ive got a mac code on the way, so i should soon be with BE
Thanks for the advice guys. Il revive this thread when ive switched and let you know what my speeds are like compared to AOL