**Summer Transfer Thread: News, Rumours and Speculation**

Spurr is better defensively, but overall Naughton wins out. This is also according to my Wednesday mates.


I personally thought that every time I saw Naughton he was just far too good to be in the Championship, looks like he's ready for the prem, and a team that's high up too.

I can't see him not starting straight away for whoever he decides to sign for. And I wish him all the best in the future, brilliant little player, and he could go far.
 
I can really see the man city team working as a unit.

Mark hughes has been quite clever hes bought quality players that are PROVEN in the premiership, none of the signings are a gamble, they wont need time to adapt to the premiership.

They know the other players they will face week in week out

Are you serious?
Even if you look at it from a pure footballing standpoint, with out my red blinkers on-

Tevez, works hard, isnt a goal machine.

Santa Cruz, has had one decent season in his entire career, in 295 apps, he has scored 85 goals. That is not a great record.

Adebayor (if he signs) Hated by Arsenal fans because he is lazy, and his decision making is comical at best. Again, has had one decent season in his entire career.

So, yes those strikers are better than what they have, but those strikers have also been playing or have played in front of midfields and defences that are literally light years ahead of Citys as it stands, and they still were no great shakes.

Even the signing of Gareth Barry, Liverpool fans were up in arms because he isnt good enough to be talked about transferring to a top four club and he certainly wouldnt displace anybody in any of the top fours midfield, so how is he all of a sudden going to be turning in the kind of performances that are going to drive City to the top of the tree? Even when he plays with the "Best Midfielder in the world"tm beside him for england, he still looks one paced and and decidedly average.

I dont see any of those signings as enough to push city any higher than snaffling a Uefa Cup spot, I think Everton, Villa, Spurs and Arsenal are better then them all over the park as it stands.
 
atpbx sorry mate but i pretty much disagree with everything you have just said

Tevez will score a lot more goals at man city than he did at utd, tevez needs games, something he was never going ot be given under fergie once berbatov was signed.

Barry is a class act, hes a battler and deserves to be an england regular, something which he may now become now hes at city if they start raising eyebrows this season.
 
LOL at the scenes on ssn where Tevez just arrived to make his press conference at Man City...got absolutely swamped with fans trying to get a hold of him:p:D
 
Not a chance, even with the united midfield being the complete shambles that it is at the minute, he still wouldnt get in.

Haha, you're definitely not thinking straight if you think Fletcher or Anderson would keep Barry out of Man Utd's team ..
 
Barry is a class act, hes a battler and deserves to be an england regular, something which he may now become now hes at city if they start raising eyebrows this season.

IF and I do mean IF Hargreaves is finally fit again, you wont see Barry start another England game for the rest of his career, what is he going to start doing that is going to turn him into this amazing player?
 
RvP is a goal scorer, 20 last season!

TO be fair thats all competitions, Bergkamp was scoring above a 0.5 goals per game ratio in Holland and only approached that in one year at Arsenal, other years he had near enough 30 appearances with less than 5 goals in the league.

20 goals in the league is pretty different to 20 in all competitions, RVP isn't an out and out goalscorer but then he wasn't a Hunterlaar/RVN type scorer in Holland either.

The other guys, Berg's included, scored FAR higher in Holland than anywhere else. Rvn is one of the few to score similarly to how he did in Holland, but then he's a poacher and always has been, its fairly difficult to compare different types of players in different leagues. Alves for instance, scored loads at a top team in Holland, and went to a, lets be honest, not free scoring or brilliant supporting midfielders Boro team so its unlikely he'd score as many, though he also hasn't looked like he would have gotten more if he was at a top 4 club.

Barry wouldn't walk into the Utd midfield because, he's an offensive player and has been for years, with Carrick absolutely horrible defensively he needs a strong defensive player alongside him, when he plays with Anderson he's horrible playing the deeper role of the two.

Barry is very good though and frankly, his crossing is still world class, his cross to set up the goal against Utd was utterly superb, one of the best in the season and he can do that consistantly, he could make a very good left winger at many clubs, infact Utd, Chelsea, Arsenal all lack great left wingers(ignoring Rooney as he's not a natural left winger probably). He gets more goals and assists in his years as a wide left than Nani, Giggs of late, Kalou/Malouda.

Even for England alongside Lampard he gets forward a LOT with Lampard taking responsibility and dropping deep very often, and Barry looked defensively weak in most of englands game, I have no idea why people consider him defensively strong, for years his game has been offensive.
 
What does Barry do better than Fletcher?

Bearing in mind what I what I think of Fletcher.

For a start he's technically far better. Way more experienced, better in the tackle, better at set pieces. Actually I'm not even carrying on as Barry is just better than Fletcher.
 
In fairness Barry would walk straight into the manyoo side alongside Carrick.

If he's that good then why's he been at Villa all these years? To be honest I dont even think given his track record the fact that Rafa/Liverpool were after him last summer is anything for Barry to be proud of

Haha, you're definitely not thinking straight if you think Fletcher or Anderson would keep Barry out of Man Utd's team ..

For a start he's technically far better. Way more experienced, better in the tackle, better at set pieces. Actually I'm not even carrying on as Barry is just better than Fletcher.

Fletcher's range of passing is so far superior to Barry's it's not even a debate, when has Barry ever completely nullified your midfield? I ask the question because Fletch does it every time he plays against you. The only things Barry has over Fletcher is a goal threat and..... oh actually that's it
 
For a start he's technically far better. Way more experienced, better in the tackle, better at set pieces. Actually I'm not even carrying on as Barry is just better than Fletcher.

Barrys faster, technically better as you said, better shot, more assists, he's just flat out better all over.

THe only thing that really winds me up about the Adebayor deal is how someone so freaking inept is going to make 8mil a year, that just winds me up no end. Can't be happier he's going(supposedly) but jesus does it make me angry they will pay him so much. He'll end up on the bench with a manager with better options and the balls to drop him. 8mil a year to ride the bench, 4mil takehome, to sit on a bench, excluding what you think will be 2-5mil signing on bonus.


AS for people saying Lampard isn't quality, he is, he's probably the best england has to offer and is better than Vieira, by a long shot. THeres two sides to this argument, people who overhype english players because they are english (Crouch, Theo, Lennon, Bentley, Johnson, Downing, the other Johnson, etc, etc, etc) but it works the opposite way for others who insist people who actually are good like Lampard and Terry are only seen as good because they are english and they massively over rate foreign players and leagues just because they aren't English. Which if you've seen Vieira play in the past 4 years you would never come close to suggesting he's better than Lampard.
 
Last edited:
For a start he's technically far better. Way more experienced, better in the tackle, better at set pieces. Actually I'm not even carrying on as Barry is just better than Fletcher.

You mean 25 year old, Captain of his country, league winning, FA cup winning, Carling Cup winning, Champions league regular Darren Fletcher?

And 28 year old, done none of the above Gareth Barry?

The only thing Gareth Barry has proved himself better at being than Darren Fletcher is that so far he has proved himself better at being 28 years old.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom