The England Cricket Thread

Why does Broad sometimes deliver at nigh on 90mph then the next spell he's lobbing it down at a military 83?

Disappointing first test, didn't think they'd win so quickly in the 4th but then capitulation is hardly unheard of.

Hoping for some improvement at least. Wonder which heads will roll...

Best plan for Smith is to stop booing him, as I don't think the Australian psyche allows for anything other than resilience and obstinacy in the face of that kind of taunting.
 
Again you're ignoring the main point I keep trying to drill into you. Trescothick and possibly other members of the England '05 Ashes team planned and premeditated and a plan to cheat by ball tampering and didn't get any punishment, Faf Du Plessis did likewise and got a fine but didn't miss any games. If Cricket Australia had left the punishment to the ICC then he would have been banned for one game. Why are you so obsessed with these three when so many others have cheated in the same way and received a far smaller/no punishment at all?

I'm just waiting for you to peddle out the "spirit of cricket" nonsense that people who talk of the "integrity of the game" and "morals" use! If we're going to start banning everybody who cheats, what about all the batsmen who nick behind and don't walk? The fielders who claim grounded catches? What about teams that ping the ball straight into the ground from in close to rough it up?.

Very probably because those players aren't involved in this match, or any match from recent memory. However whilst we're on the subject, had we had this conversation 14 years ago I'd be saying the same thing, they'd be done for life if it was up to me.

A nick behind and not walking is a completely different scenario, as is every other scenario you've given. You're comparing apples to oranges.
 
Last edited:
England wins by cheating in 2005. England fans: 'Give them OBEs!'

Australia wins without cheating in 2019. England fans: 'Dirty cheats!'

A nick behind and not walking is a completely different scenario

Why? It's still cheating when you know you hit it, as Broad admitted.
 
Last edited:
England wins by cheating in 2005. England fans: 'Give them OBEs!'

Australia wins without cheating in 2019. England fans: 'Dirty cheats!'

Over a quarter of the Australian 11 are proven filthy cheats, fact.

Why? It's still cheating when you know you hit it, as Broad admitted.

One is premeditated and an intent to cheat, the other is in the moment. Either way that's something the Umpire should see and give out, it's not Broad's place to give himself out.

It's a bit like football, would I ban someone for life for diving? Of course not. Would I ban someone for life for match fixing? Too right I would.
 
Last edited:
In cricket it kinda is.
Yep honesty and integrity goes a long way.

Finding McBains comments amusing in all honesty lol. Extremely butthurt that England were beaten by the Aussies who played much better cricket over 5 days than what England conjured up.

Fact is both Warner and Smith have served their punishment, time to let it go.
 
Yep honesty and integrity goes a long way.

Finding McBains comments amusing in all honesty lol. Extremely butthurt that England were beaten by the Aussies who played much better cricket over 5 days than what England conjured up.

Fact is both Warner and Smith have served their punishment, time to let it go.

The bottom line is it will never be 'let go', all three will always have an asterisk against their names and that's the way it is. Rightly so.
 
Last edited:
Isn't it obvious from the number of DRS reviews that overturn refused appeals for caught that quite often the batsman doesn't know they have hit it ? They can't all be hoping that no review is called.......can they ?
 
Moeen dropped and Rashid ruled out for the rest of the summer.

No surprise at Leech being called up, but he's not going to strike fear into the Aussie batting line-up.
 
The only interesting decision is whether they go for Denly or Curran. I'd favour Curran, move Stokes to 4 and bowl him a bit less. Suspect they'll stick with Denly
 
Back
Top Bottom