I spoke to soon. I restarted so I could redo my CPU OC and test stability with that and it didn't POST again. So, in conclusion:
XMP didn't work
Manual timings didn't work
1.4v didn't work
After bios reset:
XMP didn't work
Manual timings didn't work
XMP then changing to 1.4v worked for 2 POSTs and failed on the third
XMP didn't work
Manual timings didn't work
1.4v didn't work
After bios reset:
XMP didn't work
Manual timings didn't work
XMP then changing to 1.4v worked for 2 POSTs and failed on the third