Horses for courses as they say. If you drive a car for a living, e.g. taxi, or you commute through big traffic jams everyday, and auto cannot be beaten. However, if you actually enjoy driving, enjoy extracting the best out of your car by your own skill, not a computers, enjoy the feeling of a perfectly timed gearchange and the exhaust note during a good downchange then you'll know that a real drivers car won't have an auto box.