Castration for sex offenders?

Burnsy2023 said:
You're over way simplifying why people offend. People do it for the power trips, because of social reasons and many others. Lack of testosterone doesn't stop this, and the adrenal gland also produces the hormone.

This problem is much more complicated than most people here seem to think.
Click to expand...
True, I think it really depends on each individual case, people who do it for power trips for example rather than sexual gratification probably won't benefit from choosing this course of treatment. however on the other hand it could well be viable where the the reasons behind the behavior is related to sexual urges rather than masochistic or feeling power over other people.

I guess an example it could be a solution for a paedophile who although has not directly abused a child has downloaded material and fears that he could do something that he would regret in the future. If the offender and an expert psychological analysis come to the conclusion that it's a problem based on frustration of sexual urges that can't be fulfilled then surely removing the urges is a suitable solution.

i'm certainly not saying it's a cover all solution and should be looked into on a case by case basis.
 
Last edited:
In the scheme of things castration should be voluntary, then innocents and wrongly convicted don't loose something.

As for harsher sentencing some sentences seem too short and others overly long in comparison. It has to be understood that its not just the judge who sentences off the cuff although some have and been exposed as doing such things either too light or harsh. There is a myriad of background information that the public will never hear and this contributes to the final sentence levied.

As for 'cushy' or even bearable prison time, for pedophiles and rapists or sexual offenders of any kind this dose not exist. They are already on the bottom rung of the food chain in society but in prison they don't even figure as part of anything.

They are hunted like vermin every day; in fact vermin would have a better time as they would be able to hide, these prisoners have no hiding place. They are locked up with no place to run or hide and every other prisoner is out to get them every minute they are inside. Some people want them tortured; they are daily and it will never stop, they are surrounded by people who will take every opportunity to harm; maim and even kill them. Now some will say its not right; I say this, those individuals created fear and caused harm, they now have the fear and are harmed, they reap what they sow and may they reap it as long as possible.
 
Funny the ammount of people who think castration involes removing the penis. It removes the testicles.

While we are on the subject of the penis you dont need a penis to rape someone.

On the subject I think that if someone whould like to have their testicles removed, wether they are a rapist or not, they should be allowed to. But ESP if you have commited a sexual offence, why not let a sexual offender have their testicles removed? At least it shows a want to change?

They do this in america too, it can help someone get out of years of being in prison, but they also have to pass a test where they have to watch videos relating to your crime, with thingimy bob electrodes attached to their sexy bits to see if they respond.

So, yes, I think I'm in the camp that should allow sex offender to have their testicles removed, willingly.

Chemical castration, hmmm, not convinced, they could stop taking their medication.
 
Eye for an Eye IMO

If a dude rapes a girl, he should be sent to prison and subjected to daily raping by a transgender, S&M fetish loving prisoner called Emily or Steve, depending if they're pre-op lol
 
Jay794 said:
Eye for an Eye IMO

If a dude rapes a girl, he should be sent to prison and subjected to daily raping by a transgender, S&M fetish loving prisoner called Emily or Steve, depending if they're pre-op lol
Click to expand...

I honestly can't even be bothered to explain how wrong you are and to nit pick that statement. Dross.

You're wrong though.
 
Tummy said:
I honestly can't even be bothered to explain how wrong you are and to nit pick that statement. Dross.

You're wrong though.
Click to expand...

Are you trying to justify rape? or defend it? :eek: How can you disagree with my statement? rape is never ok, there are girls that will sleep with you for money if you need it that badly, no need to hide in the bushes and follow vunerable girls down alley ways
 
Last edited:
Jay794 said:
Are you trying to justify rape? or defend it? :eek: How can you disagree with my statement? rape is never ok, there are girls that will sleep with you for money if you need it that badly, no need to hide in the bushes and follow vunerable girls down alley ways
Click to expand...

You're the one who just promoted rape... :confused:
 
Jay794 said:
Are you trying to justify rape? or defend it? :eek: How can you disagree with my statement? rape is never ok, there are girls that will sleep with you for money if you need it that badly, no need to hide in the bushes and follow vunerable girls down alley ways
Click to expand...

Why arent you banned yet?
 
Jay794 said:
Are you trying to justify rape? or defend it? :eek: How can you disagree with my statement? rape is never ok, there are girls that will sleep with you for money if you need it that badly, no need to hide in the bushes and follow vunerable girls down alley ways
Click to expand...

steve-h said:
You're the one who just promoted rape... :confused:
Click to expand...

Seriously. Jay794. I've asked you this before, do you have some sort of mental problem in understanding and making points?

Your posts are often so mind boggling baffling they stump me. You don't help yourself in the slightest.
 
Last edited:
steve-h said:
So the tax payers pay for an employed rapist.

Imagine that as a job title...
Click to expand...

Didn't think of it like that, but they already kind of do, rape is already happening in prison

Angst said:
Why arent you banned yet?
Click to expand...

....because I didn't do anything wrong? I've stayed away from Castiel and Tummys argument for that exact reason.

Tummy said:
Seriously. Jay794. I've asked you this before, do you have some sort of mental problem in understanding and making points?
Click to expand...

You have asked me before and I'm pretty sure I answered that.

Maybe I misunderstood but how can anybody not be castrated or even executed for rape? (outside of prison)
 
Last edited:
Why even bring this up on this forum, most people here really cant argue anything without being crude or uncivilised.

It is quite clearly a mental state, chopping off some giblets wont change that, it may infringe on it, but otherwise you probably just made a murderer out of that man.

So well done. :mad:
 
StriderX said:
It is quite clearly a mental state, chopping off some giblets wont change that, it may infringe on it, but otherwise you probably just made a murderer out of that man.
Click to expand...

I think it would do. If you've got no nuts then you're not getting horny so you don't want to mate.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom