Not trolling. I was super excited about DS3. I preordered it and started straight away last night.
In fairness, it's a fine game and I'm sure I'll play it through fully, but that's more because of a lack of other good titles than me being blown away by DS3.
Honestly, after a couple of hours of playing I was having a strong sense of deja-vu, and not in a good way. I'm saying this in the context of it being two years since the last game and understanding the importance of keeping true to the franchise, but the engine doesn't feel like it's changed much at all. It's even the same DS2 sound when you respawn at the bonfire. Same weapons (albeit with slightly improve sets) and same spells (from what I've seen).
The bosses I've fought seem decent, but that's expansion/DLC level content.
Call me old fashioned, but I expect more from a sequel otherwise after a couple of games I start making comparisons with Call of Duty.
The true test is the fact that I'd cleared the entire evening to play it tonight, and I'm not actually playing it
Personal opinion though, obvs.