Does something need to be done about dogs?

Because while every animal (and many other things) are potentially dangerous, most will only become actually dangerous if the child does not behave properly.

My friend has a very well trained Bullmastiff and a young boy (7), they were all in the living room together when one time the boy decided to stamp on the dogs tail. The dog yelped and barked but didn't attack, and the boy got a roasting - but he just did it without rhyme or reason.. Kids do the dumbest stuff sometimes :p.
 
Because while every animal (and many other things) are potentially dangerous, most will only become actually dangerous if the child does not behave properly. Fix that and you stop a good many problems from ever presenting themselves.

Between the dog and the child, the latter is easier to teach simple rules for the complex situations like these, and it's easier to test whether they understand without actually putting them in the scenario.
Between them again, it's usually the latter's behaviour that (often inadvertently) excites/upsets the dog, which is why they need to learn what they should and should never do. This is how such children grow up to be responsible adults who are not terrified of (or traumatised by) animals.

It's a bit like the rules of aviation, but with mental agility instead of aerobatic agility, in that the one with greater agility is more responsible for resolving a potential conflict. You cannot train a dog to human standards of behaviour or reason... but you can train a human like that. Dogs can be very well trained and, as with the weird aviation analogy, there is still a good amount of responsibility on the less agile to not cause or exacerbate problems too, which falls to the owner in lieu of the dog being able to converse in English.

That really misses the point of a dog being out of control - or that an owner has mistreated the dog and it is out of control because of it. There is nothing an innocent bystander can do in that situation other than to try and protect him/herself as best they can, and children are really not capable of doing that effectively. I've also said it before: large dogs have more 'potential' for inflicting serious injury than small dogs and that particularly includes dogs with powerful jaws regardless of physical size.
 
That really misses the point of a dog being out of control - or that an owner has mistreated the dog and it is out of control because of it. There is nothing an innocent bystander can do in that situation other than to try and protect him/herself as best they can, and children are really not capable of doing that effectively. I've also said it before: large dogs have more 'potential' for inflicting serious injury than small dogs and that particularly includes dogs with powerful jaws regardless of physical size.
No, that is a mostly-unrelated point.
This is about a perfectly normal, well-behaved dog being subject to kids behaving badly toward them, when the dog can do nothing other than to try and protect him/herself as best they can, and dogs are really not capable of doing that in ways socially acceptable to humans...
Size has nothing to do with it as any dog bite can still hurt a child. This is why children must be taught not to do certain things to dogs, just as they should be taught not to do certain things to each other.
 
No, that is a mostly-unrelated point.
This is about a perfectly normal, well-behaved dog being subject to kids behaving badly toward them, when the dog can do nothing other than to try and protect him/herself as best they can, and dogs are really not capable of doing that in ways socially acceptable to humans...
Size has nothing to do with it as any dog bite can still hurt a child. This is why children must be taught not to do certain things to dogs, just as they should be taught not to do certain things to each other.
I'm not sure what point is being debated here now, you are of course correct and children must be taught to respect dogs (all animals actually) and to not mistreat them. It also helps if dogs are socialised at a young age with small children which, not knowing anyone with small children at the time, is something my own dog missed out on. As a result she doesn't know what to make of them or whether they would make good playmates. But that's an aside.
 
I'm not sure what point is being debated here now, you are of course correct and children must be taught to respect dogs (all animals actually) and to not mistreat them. It also helps if dogs are socialised at a young age with small children which, not knowing anyone with small children at the time, is something my own dog missed out on. As a result she doesn't know what to make of them or whether they would make good playmates. But that's an aside.
The point is that, yes, dogs being out of control is bad and that any dog can potentially lose it and become dangerous... but in order to help prevent that scenario from happening, we first address all the issues we can, and one issue is children not knowing how to behave. Teach them and you avoid them unwittingly (or otherwise) triggering a bad response from the dog.
Risk prevention rather than mitigation.
 
The point is that, yes, dogs being out of control is bad and that any dog can potentially lose it and become dangerous... but in order to help prevent that scenario from happening, we first address all the issues we can, and one issue is children not knowing how to behave. Teach them and you avoid them unwittingly (or otherwise) triggering a bad response from the dog.
Risk prevention rather than mitigation.
I can't argue with that and would go as far as to say it could/should be explained in junior school. Opportunity is there to bring in a well-behaved dog (a guide dog or companion animal) and just spend 1 hour teaching kids how to approach and deal with dogs they might meet while playing outside. Also the warning signs the animal is not happy. I'm pretty sure schools could find that time to spare and kids would love it.
 
I can't argue with that and would go as far as to say it could/should be explained in junior school. Opportunity is there to bring in a well-behaved dog (a guide dog or companion animal) and just spend 1 hour teaching kids how to approach and deal with dogs they might meet while playing outside. Also the warning signs the animal is not happy. I'm pretty sure schools could find that time to spare and kids would love it.
Funnily enough, that's how it used to be done.
I can only presume Elf & Safety got involved somewhere along the line, round about when they stopped teaching woodwork in case kids hurt themselves on the sharp tools they were learning not to hurt themselves with...
 
I can't argue with that and would go as far as to say it could/should be explained in junior school. Opportunity is there to bring in a well-behaved dog (a guide dog or companion animal) and just spend 1 hour teaching kids how to approach and deal with dogs they might meet while playing outside. Also the warning signs the animal is not happy. I'm pretty sure schools could find that time to spare and kids would love it.

Until some idiot kid harms the dog or provokes it and one of them gets bitten...
 
The point is that, yes, dogs being out of control is bad and that any dog can potentially lose it and become dangerous... but in order to help prevent that scenario from happening, we first address all the issues we can, and one issue is children not knowing how to behave. Teach them and you avoid them unwittingly (or otherwise) triggering a bad response from the dog.
Risk prevention rather than mitigation.

Personally, I'd go with providing children with firearms.
 
Clearly not just the breed or every owner of a Pitbull would be dead or handless

Nope. It doesn't logically follow that if something is the result of some factor it will occur 100% of the time.

These dogs were bred for bloodsports, sure owner behaviour, training and environment are other factors but the breed is clearly a huge factor too, any dog can potentially snap but when a bull terrier type dog does it then the consequences can be much worse than with most dog attacks, that's entirely down to the breed.

When was the last time you heard of someone being mauled to death by a Chihuahua?
 
Back
Top Bottom