The only option is don't create life, ban it
Does something need to be done about dogs?
- Thread starter Dis86
- Start date
Soldato
There just as moody. Always hot and cold in my experience.
Its an interesting question. should we mark the death as a dog killing the person due to there being a relationship between having the dog and dyeing or is it the cows fault for killing the person so we mark it as a cow death? I suppose its the same with baths really. Was it the Baths fault for killing people? Baring in mind it was in its natural habitat in the "bathroom" minding its own business causing no deaths but strangely enough 9/10 people who died in the bath which I would like to add is roughly 5 x the amount as dogs had their clothes on the floor... so should we really mark it down as death by clothes? Its an interesting conundrum.
Soldato
- Joined
- 25 Nov 2005
- Posts
- 12,611
Well if they were walking without the dog, would the cow have killed them ? It's like deaths "with" covid, is it the covid that killed them or did they just happened to have covid when they died
Soldato
Are you being facetious? I haven't kept up with the thread (boringWell if they were walking without the dog, would the cow have killed them ? It's like deaths "with" covid, is it the covid that killed them or did they just happened to have covid when they died
) to get context but a lot of cow attacks are due to people saving their dogs from them. Cows don't like dogs.Interestingly in scenarios of dog walker vs. cow the dog being let go of (essentially off lead) is safer. Most tramples happen when people try to defend their dogs.
Also, you can't ban dogs from farmland that has public footpaths through it. Also, farm owners can and will shoot out of control dogs on their land, as a result we keep ours on lead when there is a chance they could bolt after something on private land.
Soldato
- Joined
- 25 Nov 2005
- Posts
- 12,611
I mean you can, you just don't want to
Are you being facetious? I haven't kept up with the thread (boring
It's more that they are curious. There's no vendetta between the species.
Correct. I'd like to ban loads of things I don't like, but restriction and laws have unintended consequences, so while not totally opposed to changing things, generally I'm on the side of self regulation.
Tends to be cows with calves at foot which really people should learn by now aren't cute and friendly but rather protective and mildly scary at times
Soldato
No, they really don't like them.
My father in law has both cows and a dog. I've seen it in action
Soldato
No, they really don't like them.
My father in law has both cows and a dog. I've seen it in action
I've got a dog with cow patterns and colouring. I'll have to send her in to investigate this hatred.
To bring the thread back on topic, there is a discussion to be had regarding dog ownership around children. Bringing a child into the home of an established dog/owner relationship can sometimes be tricky at best and dangerous at worst. Problem being you're going into the private choices and lives of people within their own walls. It's a tricky one. Maybe there should be more guidance and some sort of safety course made available for dog owners during the pregnancy to at least attempt to educate about the possible dangers. Unsure what you can do for already established families bringing puppies/dogs into the mix, could this be something the breeders be made to be responsible for? It may discourage breeders taking risks selling to families. Unsure how rescues do it?
I bet most parents mixing kids and dogs were brought up with a family dog, as a result maybe overly confident as everything was fine with them. Who knows what goes through the mind of families to do it, the parents that lost their child the other week will likely never forgive themselves.
Soldato
Well if they were walking without the dog, would the cow have killed them ? It's like deaths "with" covid, is it the covid that killed them or did they just happened to have covid when they died
So there are very few deaths by cows, however as you say a large percentage of those are by people with dogs but this still makes it a very very small amount of cases. So based on your thinking it's the dog being with them which has resulted in them being killed. Now when we look at the larger statistics of the total amount of dog walkers who pass cows with their dogs, which must be in the millions of encounters over the year. 99.9999% of these encounters resulted in the dog walkers not being killed by cows, even though they had a dog with them. So surely the opposite is equally as true if the dog is responsible for the death due to them being with the person while being killed by a cow. Then they are also responsible for them not being killed on the 99.9999% of times the dog walkers were not attacked?
Soldato
- Joined
- 18 May 2010
- Posts
- 12,785
My recent experience, application form for dog of interest which you could lie on. State your address, home and garden details, if you have kids, experience with dogs etc
If selected as a potential adopter from the form then virtual tour of home and garden or in person visit
If successful from the tour then 3 visits to the dog at the kennels, second including the kids and pick up on the 3rd visit
Soldato
- Joined
- 21 Sep 2020
- Posts
- 4,185
This so much.
So pretty stringent and always room for improvement. Same with breeders.
All your left with then is the families that get a pup/dog from a "mate" or someone down the pub. That's something that needs to be stopped before you get the point of applying more controls.
Soldato
- Joined
- 25 Nov 2005
- Posts
- 12,611
Well if we go that route then kids are safer to have a dog than not because the statistics are equally as small ?
Soldato
A legal requirement to have dogs trained and this checked by a qualified person. This should be particularly stringent on any breeds that are crossed with illegal breeds. A bit like giving the dog something equivalent to a driving license, it is trained how to behave. If the owner is not appropriately looking after the dog then that would be reflected during the checks it has across its lifetime.
Soldato