Ermm ok. We'll leave it here because you seem to be changing what you're saying in every post.
We'll never know whether it went in but Carroll shouldn't have given Cech a chance.
FA CUP FINAL Chelsea v Liverpool *** Spoilers ***
- Thread starter Cosimo
- Start date
Ermm ok. We'll leave it here because you seem to be changing what you're saying in every post.
We'll never know whether it went in but Carroll shouldn't have given Cech a chance.
Soldato
- Joined
- 30 Aug 2009
- Posts
- 8,112
- Location
- one nation under sony
just saw the gif at first I thought clear goal
then I saw this
not sure now
then I saw this
not sure now
Soldato
- Joined
- 14 Oct 2007
- Posts
- 9,367
- Location
- newcastle
I have to agree with you their I hardly heard his name said in the whole of he game and there were at least three players that were better today
All I've said is that from what I can see, it didn't seem to have crossed the line.
At first I said that it has to have clearly crossed the line to be a goal and I still stand by that fact. It cannot have clearly crossed the line.
But yes, Carroll should have buried it, he actually headed it at Cech.
Caporegime
- Joined
- 18 Oct 2002
- Posts
- 33,188
There were few players(chelsea side ) who were worse than Mata, he did nothing, useless offensively, useless defensively. He looked shattered despite in this game(and most of the other big games lately) running less and doing less than everyone else.
He's spanish, that is my reasoning for him getting MOTM. Start of the season, Silva or Mata touched the ball, fluffed a pass it was still magic. It's insane the "they're Spanish, Spain is awesome, Barca are spanish, these spanish players must be brilliant" mentality here this season.
Mata was lazy, useless and did almost nothing today. Ramires/Drogba did far far more, Ramires was quite lazy with his defending today and looked shattered, however he ran himself ragged against Barca(while Mata certainly didn't). Drogba was closing down bigger distances, more often and faster in the last 20 mins than any other Chelsea player.
Ivanovic was also insanely good today, made some incredibly good blocks and clearances and a couple fantastic tackles in the box.
Probably should have gone Drogba, maybe Ivanovic/Ramires, or Lampard, who also worked VERY hard today and his passing was frequently brilliant finding players to get the ball out when other people weren't able to.
) who were worse than Mata, he did nothing, useless offensively, useless defensively. He looked shattered despite in this game(and most of the other big games lately) running less and doing less than everyone else.He's spanish, that is my reasoning for him getting MOTM. Start of the season, Silva or Mata touched the ball, fluffed a pass it was still magic. It's insane the "they're Spanish, Spain is awesome, Barca are spanish, these spanish players must be brilliant" mentality here this season.
Mata was lazy, useless and did almost nothing today. Ramires/Drogba did far far more, Ramires was quite lazy with his defending today and looked shattered, however he ran himself ragged against Barca(while Mata certainly didn't). Drogba was closing down bigger distances, more often and faster in the last 20 mins than any other Chelsea player.
Ivanovic was also insanely good today, made some incredibly good blocks and clearances and a couple fantastic tackles in the box.
Probably should have gone Drogba, maybe Ivanovic/Ramires, or Lampard, who also worked VERY hard today and his passing was frequently brilliant finding players to get the ball out when other people weren't able to.
Not the most memorable of finals I guess as neither team are capable of playing stunning attacking football but on the whole I think the better team won.
Drogba owns Wembley and when he can be arsed he's a world beater, I thought Mikel had a good game too, along with the rest of our defence, except Bosingwa.
As for Carroll's miss with the header he should've buried it but instead gave Cech the chance to make an excellent save and the lino a chance to make an excellent (and correct) decision. Quite simply the whole ball didn't cross the whole line as all the pictures, gifs & simulations show. There isn't one that shows a complete sphere with daylight between it and the line, even if there was, what goes around come around hey Liverpool?
Happy days
Drogba owns Wembley and when he can be arsed he's a world beater, I thought Mikel had a good game too, along with the rest of our defence, except Bosingwa.
As for Carroll's miss with the header he should've buried it but instead gave Cech the chance to make an excellent save and the lino a chance to make an excellent (and correct) decision. Quite simply the whole ball didn't cross the whole line as all the pictures, gifs & simulations show. There isn't one that shows a complete sphere with daylight between it and the line, even if there was, what goes around come around hey Liverpool?
Happy days
Not the most memorable of finals I guess as neither team are capable of playing stunning attacking football but on the whole I think the better team won.
Drogba owns Wembley and when he can be arsed he's a world beater, I thought Mikel had a good game too, along with the rest of our defence, except Bosingwa.
As for Carroll's miss with the header he should've buried it but instead gave Cech the chance to make an excellent save and the lino a chance to make an excellent (and correct) decision. Quite simply the whole ball didn't cross the whole line as all the pictures, gifs & simulations show. There isn't one that shows a complete sphere with daylight between it and the line, even if there was, what goes around come around hey Liverpool?
Happy days
Correct decision was made in 05
, would have suited us better if not given with Cech sent off and a penalty anyways .
Great banner.
Correct decision was made in 05
The correct decision would mean that the whole ball definitely crossed the whole line, was that the case?
The correct decision was made today as the whole ball definitely didn't cross the whole line.
Yes? As in yes it definitely crossed the line? There must be some images out there to back that up if that's the case?
It's not inconclusive today, it didn't cross the line, as all the images out there prove so it's conclusive.
It's not inconclusive today, it didn't cross the line, as all the images out there prove so it's conclusive.
Associate
- Joined
- 2 Jan 2010
- Posts
- 2,307
So they ****ed up majorly yet it was inconclusive? Have you finally given up the die-hard "Us against the world" Liverpool moto and realised that it was impossible for the linesman to judge it and therefore give it as a goal..
Yeah there are, didn't you watch the match back then?
Plenty of images today to suggest it could have crossed the line too
just saw the gif at first I thought clear goal
then I saw this
not sure now
By the way, forum rules state no hot-linking to images. host it elsewhere.
What is that whole rule about?
In the past people would hotlink stuff and then the host would change the image to something very naughty with "Stop leeching" type messages, not that it bothers me.
Yeah there are, didn't you watch the match back then?
Plenty of images today to suggest it could have crossed the line too
I did and still to this day I haven't seen any proof that it crossed line, but that's not a problem as I'm not claiming it did.
Images that suggest it could've crossed the line?
If you've seen those fabled images why do you think it's inconclusive?