COD4 was not GOTY, came 2nd, 1st only in its class.
I HAVE posted this many times since the day of the awards hosted by Samuel L. Jackson on SPIKE TV.
BioShock was GOTY, COD4 MW was best in its cat, even the fact Bioshock was not on the PS3 did not let COD4 which was get ahead in the votes.
Here is the official list of VGA award winners:
Game of the Year: BioShock (XBOX360, PC)
Studio of the Year: Harmonix
Best Shooter: Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (XBOX360, PC, PS3)
Best Role-Playing Game: Mass Effect (XBOX360)
Best Military Game: Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (XBOX360, PC, PS3)
Best Individual Sports Game: skate (XBOX360, PS3)
Best Handheld Game: The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass (Nintendo DS)
Best Graphics: Crysis (PC)
Best Game Based on a Movie or TV Show: The Simpsons Game (XBOX360, Nintendo Wii, PS2, PS3, Nintendo DS, PSP)
Best Rhythm Game: Rock Band (XBOX360, PS2, PS3)
Best Driving Game: DiRT (XBOX360, PC, PS3)
Best Action Game: Super Mario Galaxy (Nintendo Wii)
Best Team Sports Game: Madden NFL 08 (XBOX360, Nintendo Wii, PS3, PC, Nintendo DS, PlayStation Portable, PlayStation 2, Xbox, Nintendo GameCube, Mac OS X)
Best Soundtrack: Rock Band (XBOX360, PS2, PS3)
Breakthrough Technology: The Orange Box/ Portal (XBOX360, PC, PS3)
Best XBOX360 Game: BioShock (XBOX360, PC)
Best Wii Game: Super Mario Galaxy (Nintendo Wii)
Best PS3 Game: Ratchet & Clank Future: Tools of Destruction (PS3)
Best PC Game: The Orange Box (PC, XBOX360, PS3)
Best Original Score: BioShock (XBOX360, PC)
Best Multiplayer Game: Halo 3 (XBOX360)
Most Addictive Video Game fueled by Dew: Halo 3 (XBOX360)