Do my eyes deceive me or are you asking me to do the work to fix your broken evidence source?
The answer is no. If you're convinced the method is fine and the author discredited their comparison for no reason then fix the comparison and demonstrate to the same audience you found it in.
You stated it is broken, you got to prove it. Really is that simple. If you cant be bothered doing the mathlab stuff etc. Showing his program is wrong. Making sure the images are the same frames. How can I judge you. I never bothered.