Soldato
I've driven a 182 briefly and it was appreciably quicker and revvier (and sweeter sounding) than a standard ST, but the driving position, seats and interior were not as good as in the Ford. The whole interior as whole seemed a generation back from the facelift Fiesta to me.
Handling wise I didn't think there was much in it really in all honesty (this was comparing my ST which was stock at the time, to a stock 182), the Clio felt lighter on its feet and a little more eager to turn in, possibly thanks to smaller wheels/narrower rubber, but it didn't shame the Ford handling wise as far as I'm concerned. I must stress as I was borrowing a mates car (the Clio) I was not pushing it hard.
I liked the 182 a lot but was put off by the horror stories in terms of reliability and running costs (exhausts, driveshafts, electrical gremlins, expensive cambelt changes) and I didn't like the interior at all. In my view the Ford looks significantly better inside and out and costs less to run....for me that swung it. The 182 is probably the better drivers car if thats all you cared about, but a better everday car? In my opinion the pluses in pace did not override the things that concerned me about it as an ownership prospect.
I've not driven a 197 or 200, I expect them to be better as an overall package than both the Fiesta or previous gen Clio but then they are a newer and more expensive car
All in my opinion
Handling wise I didn't think there was much in it really in all honesty (this was comparing my ST which was stock at the time, to a stock 182), the Clio felt lighter on its feet and a little more eager to turn in, possibly thanks to smaller wheels/narrower rubber, but it didn't shame the Ford handling wise as far as I'm concerned. I must stress as I was borrowing a mates car (the Clio) I was not pushing it hard.
I liked the 182 a lot but was put off by the horror stories in terms of reliability and running costs (exhausts, driveshafts, electrical gremlins, expensive cambelt changes) and I didn't like the interior at all. In my view the Ford looks significantly better inside and out and costs less to run....for me that swung it. The 182 is probably the better drivers car if thats all you cared about, but a better everday car? In my opinion the pluses in pace did not override the things that concerned me about it as an ownership prospect.
I've not driven a 197 or 200, I expect them to be better as an overall package than both the Fiesta or previous gen Clio but then they are a newer and more expensive car
All in my opinion