FIFA rejects FA's poppy appeal

Soldato
Joined
14 Oct 2003
Posts
13,485
Location
South Derbyshire
FIFA has rejected the Football Association's renewed appeal for England players to be allowed to have embroidered Remembrance Day poppies on their shirts on Saturday.

The FA made a special request to FIFA for permission to wear the poppies for this weekend's international friendly against Spain in honour of members of the armed forces who have died in the line of duty.

The world body has now issued a "final statement'' rejecting the plea.

A letter from FIFA to the FA sent today said: "We regret to inform you that accepting such initiatives would open the door to similar initiatives from all over the world, jeopardising the neutrality of football. Therefore, we confirm herewith that the suggested embroidery on the match shirt cannot be authorised.

"There are a variety of options where the FA can continue supporting the cause of remembrance. One of them already was approved by FIFA, the period of silence.''

Earlier, Britain's FIFA vice-president Jim Boyce added his voice to calls for the world governing body to permit England's players to wear poppies on their shirts.

"Personally I think there has to be a bit of common sense used when requests like this come in," the Northern Irishman said. "Armistice Day is a very important day in the FA calendar, as it is with other associations, and I don't think it would offend anybody to have a poppy on the shirts.

"I am not involved in the decision and I do understand there have to be rules. But as this is a special request from a member of FIFA and is not of a political nature I believe that common sense should prevail and that it should be looked at in a different light.''

FIFA has allowed a minute's silence to be held before the sell-out game, for the England players to wear poppies on their training kit at Wembley on Friday, and to stand for the traditional two minutes' silence to mark the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11 month on Friday.

FIFA's rules prevent anything of a political nature being worn on shirts and although the organisation does not regard poppies as political, it is concerned it would open the door to countries wanting to wear various different emblems on their shirts, some of which would be overtly political.

Sports minister Hugh Robertson also wrote to FIFA today urging it to rethink for both the England game and Wales' match against Norway.

Robertson's letter said: "We fully understand, and respect, FIFA's rules on its member nations not adorning their shirts with 'commercial', 'political', or 'religious' symbols or messages. The FA and FAW do not intend to contravene these rules.

"However, the British public feel very strongly about this issue which is seen as an act of national remembrance to commemorate those who gave their lives in the service of their country. It is not religious or political in any way.''

http://sport.uk.msn.com/football/news/fifa-rejects-fas-poppy-appeal?ucsort=1&ucpg=2#ic-anchor


This is well out of order, FIFA should be ashamed tbh and FA should just ignore them and do it anyway. wasn't for lives of our fallen that stupid frog in charge wouldn't be there.
 
FIFA are merely trying to be neutral and if they apply this to every other country I don't see it being an issue. Don't get me wrong I respect what our soldiers did and went through as much as the next man. They have allowed a minutes silence before the start of the game.

It would be good to see an English player score and remove his shirt to show a massive poppy. I cant see England scoring against Spain tho :D
 
I've already replied to someones status on Facebook about this but ill put my reply here.

I personally don't see the problem. the rules state no country is wallowed to add anything to their shirts. It is the same rule for all countries we are not being singled out.

They can wear the poppy's before the game & afterwards.

It is lame yes but the rule applies to all.
 
I've already replied to someones status on Facebook about this but ill put my reply here.

I personally don't see the problem. the rules state no country is wallowed to add anything to their shirts. It is the same rule for all countries we are not being singled out.

They can wear the poppy's before the game & afterwards.

It is lame yes but the rule applies to all.


Not to mention they could wear Poppy design armbands, afaik some lower league club did this.
 
There is one rule for all. It’s not been an issue before and I don’t see why it should be one now. We can wear poppies, there will be a minutes silence and I don't have a problem with it. It’s just another example of FA ineptitude, creating a mountain out of a mole hill.
 
Don't understand the furore, maybe it was a slow day at the Daily Mail so they drummed this up. It's hardly a big deal, there can be a respectful reminder before the game.
 
g_robson: @TonyBarretTimes : RT @Mr_JMB: England v Sweden 10 Nov 2001. No poppy on shirts, no black armband. Do you remember any media storm?

RickLee14: @TonyBarretTimes last year we played on remembrance sunday vs Brazil (14/11/10) no poppies on shirt no black armbands worn.

says it all.
 
g_robson: @TonyBarretTimes : RT @Mr_JMB: England v Sweden 10 Nov 2001. No poppy on shirts, no black armband. Do you remember any media storm?

RickLee14: @TonyBarretTimes last year we played on remembrance sunday vs Brazil (14/11/10) no poppies on shirt no black armbands worn.

says it all.

That does say it all. The papers are loving the "drama"...!
 
Daily Mail always do this, last year a few clubs didn't wear poppies and they practically outed them as Nazis.

I remember that, they did it with United one year and I think Liverpool as well, they wouldn't let it drop, I don't think you should be forced or pressured into wearing one.

It seems to be more of an advertisement nowadays, perhaps that's a good thing.
 
It happens once a year to show respect for the fallen soldiers that have died for their country.

How anyone could have a problem with this is beyond me, they should be ashamed of themselves.
 
I remember that, they did it with United one year and I think Liverpool as well, they wouldn't let it drop, I don't think you should be forced or pressured into wearing one.

It seems to be more of an advertisement nowadays, perhaps that's a good thing.

Why because both clubs have foreign owners, they should be exempt?

Last time I looked both clubs were English, Therefore they shouldn't need to be asked twice.

No respect at all.
 
Why because both clubs have foreign owners, they should be exempt?

Last time I looked both clubs were English, Therefore they shouldn't need to be asked twice.

No respect at all.

No, just because of choice.

Can't you have respect without showing it?
 
Why because both clubs have foreign owners, they should be exempt?

Last time I looked both clubs were English, Therefore they shouldn't need to be asked twice.

No respect at all.

It's not a law It should be up to any individual or organisation how they want to remember them. It has nothing to do with respect or the nationality of the owners :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top Bottom