When you lose physical condition and you have no talent, you have nothing, when you have talent and lose some of it, you can still be half decent. Talent is more important than ability to run a lot.
Of course it is but physical conditioning is not just the ability to run a lot. It is the ability of your muscles to work when fatigued, its your recovery ability and much more. Why have sports that are not traditionally physically demanding suddenly take a leap in performance when the top players get fitter and stronger. A player whos game depends on pace and power isn't going to last as long as one based on skill and technique. Will Robben be a top player when his pace is gone? Will Suarez be such a good striker when his pace is gone?
If Rooney had been playing for ages AND had picked up more injuries as a result and hadn't dropped off in quality way before he was 30 then year sure. Playing a couple years earlier than other players might mean he's crap at 33 rather than 35... but what 27-28 is when he got noticeably worse for wear. This is down to him personally, he's always been a hefty guy, he's never at any stage of his career carried the kind of body fat percentage Beckham or any other top pro does. He appears to not look after himself, judging by his size it doesn't appear like he eats exceptionally well and his worsening fitness, ability to work hard has gone down.
Once you reach a point where you're taking time out of the season to attend a fat camp because you started the season in such poor condition you were just embarrassing yourself it's almost certainly downhill from there. How he got new contracts after that point I don't know.
He has got a new contract because he is a large part of the United brand and partly I believe because Moyes was petrified of losing him under his watch.
He hasn't got much actual talent, there is no stand out part of his game. The only thing he had as a kid was raw power, he lost that years ago. Complete waste of space and pretty much sums up why talent is considered more important, Rooney without any fitness or workrate is actively harming the team.
Thats a ridiculous thing to say. He was hugely talented and although he never reached the heights we expected he was fantastic for nearly 10 years. He never reached the heights we thought he would but that is because we expected him to be one of the top few players in the world.
There is very little difference between Rooney and the majority of other players in terms of how hard they work. In terms of joints getting worse, training every day is just as damaging as playing a league game. He wouldn't be in any better condition if he'd not been played till he was 18.
It's embarrassing frankly, because he played 1-2 years earlier than a lot of other players he aged 7 years worse in football years, 5 years if you want to pretend he only got **** this season. Older footballers were FAR more effective when they retired than Rooney is now. Many are better than Rooney now closer to 40 than 35. People are looking to make excuses for how bad Rooney is, it's not that he's not very talented, or that he's not hugely professional for an athlete in terms of conditioning, it's that he's basically retirement age
Its a combination of things but peoples bodies age at different rates. Something as simple as the way you run or the subtle differences in a joint can have huge implications on the longevity of an athlete.
Part of his problem is that he is a victim of peoples expectations. "Hes such a good player he can play in midfield or attack". He has been moved all over the place and has been part of average Man Utd teams for the past 5 or more years. If he was playing for a top team as an out and out striker he would still be scoring a lot of goals. I can't think of many strikers bar the absolute very best ones that would be flourishing in the recent United teams and thats only because they are like a young Rooney, pacey, direct and bullish.
Martial is having a brilliant season and his goal return isn't exactly great statistically is it.
Put it this way, how many players at Rooneys age are lighting up their league with such a poor team around them or being asked to play as part of a obviously dire and crap set of tactics. Why did Ronaldinho disappear? Ronaldo? Were neither of them that good or did they just drop off a cliff for one reason or another.
Last edited: