Football in Manchester

It's a sad but not new state of lower league teams. While gestures such as the recent donation from each Premier League side for lower sides was nice, I still don't believe it's really a responsibility of the former to look after the latter.
 
Yep, that £6000 went a long way!

I firmly believe that it is the responsibilty of all clubs to look out for their peers when they're in trouble. How many kids want to grow up to be footballers? They can't all play for Man Utd you know so it's handy that we have probably the largest number of professional and semi-professional clubs where those with the talent can go to and be able to earn a little bit of money for their trouble.

If players wages were taxed by 0.1% and that money put into a central fund then Hyde, who were keen to avoid the admin route and actually pay their debt would be able to call on some readily available assistance to help prevent being wound up.
 
Yep, that £6000 went a long way!

I firmly believe that it is the responsibilty of all clubs to look out for their peers when they're in trouble. How many kids want to grow up to be footballers? They can't all play for Man Utd you know so it's handy that we have probably the largest number of professional and semi-professional clubs where those with the talent can go to and be able to earn a little bit of money for their trouble.

If players wages were taxed by 0.1% and that money put into a central fund then Hyde, who were keen to avoid the admin route and actually pay their debt would be able to call on some readily available assistance to help prevent being wound up.

So basically we should pretty much have a country of only footballers, with those who play well subsidising those who don't "make it".

Genius, clubs are BUSINESS'S , as are cinema's and film studio's and lots of other forms of entertainment. We don't pay bad actors money and crap film studio's to keep them going when they can't keep themselves going, so why should we do the same for the lower leagues.

Yes its tough to make money in the lower leagues, if it wasn't as said, there would be infinite leagues, which is unfeasable and frankly, stupid. 200million kids worldwide want to be professional footballers, only maybe 20k-30k of all of them will make it at any level of football anywhere in the world, whats so wrong with that.

I can't stand the moping about how we can't allow clubs to go under, because of their history or the fact other clubs make money. Loads of business's go under all the time, plenty with long historys and all with competitors making more money, this is life, welcome to it.

EDIT:- there are actually one or two situations I can think of, and probably others where funding a club and raising money would be well worthwhile, but being a completely unfeasable business simply is not one of them.

If, I dunno Brentford, who have very little cash but are doing ok, had say, a tragedy, bus crash maybe and literally the team was wiped out, a bunch of clubs putting some money in so they can rebuild/survive till they are back on their feet would be a very nice gesture, loaning players for free and what not. But if through years of mismanagement Brentford simply went bust and became a simply unviable club to continue on, then I can't see any reason for other clubs to offer handouts.

THe thing is, this team got 6k, and it didn't help, how much would, 100k? where does it stop, if its run the same way would they not just go bust anyway but in 4 years instead of now, at the cost of wasting someone elses money for longer?

What would they do with this money, 100k injected so they get better players, on better wages, and run out of cash faster. Its naive to think a simple cash injection would simply stop them going under, it would simply stop them going under NOW.
 
Last edited:
OK then, a different angle. Instead of expecting other clubs or players to help, how about the local people supporting their local team? Or is Manchester United in the blood of those Essex boys who go to Old Trafford every other week and unfurl their "Chelmsford Reds" banner?
 
Good grief it seems like every one of your threads is complaining how a minnow club has gone out of business because the big clubs haven't paid all their bills.
Whats wrong with that? I'm heavily involved with my club and would be devasted to see them go out of business, just as my peers at Hyde have done today.
 
OK then, a different angle. Instead of expecting other clubs or players to help, how about the local people supporting their local team? Or is Manchester United in the blood of those Essex boys who go to Old Trafford every other week and unfurl their "Chelmsford Reds" banner?

Most people just don't want to watch the kind of football you see in the lower divisions.
 
Businesses fail every single day, do you think the bigger businesses in their fields bail them out? If my local cafe was going out of business should McDonalds save them? I dont see your logic
 
OK then, a different angle. Instead of expecting other clubs or players to help, how about the local people supporting their local team? Or is Manchester United in the blood of those Essex boys who go to Old Trafford every other week and unfurl their "Chelmsford Reds" banner?

But why? What happened to choice?
 
OK then, a different angle. Instead of expecting other clubs or players to help, how about the local people supporting their local team? Or is Manchester United in the blood of those Essex boys who go to Old Trafford every other week and unfurl their "Chelmsford Reds" banner?

So not only do you think the big clubs should bail out the small clubs, you think that everyone should support their local club?

I actually think DM has more valid points than you. A person can support whoever the hell they want. You can't expect someone to give money to a club purely because they are local.
 
Football clubs are businesses, a failing club shouldn't be bailed out by a successful one.

You can't run your club in to the ground, and then expect another club to come and sort the mess out for you because they happen share the same area of the country as you.
 
And they do.

It seems to me that this is a country of football lovers who are football snobs. How many people are devoted to the big four clubs in the Premiership yet wouldn't dream of putting money over the turnstiles at the team down the road because they're "crap", even though they've never seen them play!

A wiser man than me said last night at a book launch I attended for my local football club that we are allowed to have our fantasy teams as well as supporting our local clubs too. I wish more people would see the light.
 
Back
Top Bottom