Soldato
ethos said:Because for a lot of people they hit the traps real well...
Oh and they aren't great on the shoulder, injury waiting to happen!
Why do people always feel the need to brand certain exercises bad for everyone? We're all built differently. You certainly have a point but you're bordering on scaremongering and there's so much of that on internet forums.ethos said:It's not great for your rotator cuff / shoulder- in general
I could post quotes like you have about pretty much any exercise. Aren't squats the devil spawn for causing knee injuries? Skull crushers will obliterate everyone's elbows who dares do them?
All exercises can potentially cause injury if performed with bad form, with too much weight or just generally incorrectly. Even an exercise as innocent as the simple shrug can really mess you up, do you perform these? Then have a read of this thread over on MP Shrug Science how many people do you see in the gym doing forward and backward rolling shrugs, etc?
Upright rows will hit the traps (and possibly cause most damage to shoulders) with a very narrow grip and hands almost touching. The higher the bar is brought up the higher the risk, the lower the elbows are kept, the higher the risk.
Yet performed with strict enough form, with a wider grip, elbows kept high enough and not lifted too high they can be an excellent delt builder Too much overhead pressing could kill your shoulders too. Personally I alternate between both each workout along with rotator cuff strengthening exercises.