What critics, I seem to distinctly remember saying the signings were great, they were ditching dead weight and trouble makers, and doing fantastically well financially, with an improving squad..........
I think Simpson had a, dodgy game, mostly the first 15-20 mins though, his clearances and passing was woeful but he did improve. Gutierez was freaking awesome throughout defensively just brilliant, offensively decent but not great.
Ba looked quality for West Ham, good buy, was he on a free, I can't quite remember, another truly strange decision by West Ham, I think they paid a decent fee for him, but gave him a clause to go on a free if they got relegated, he's a 15mil striker easily, maybe 10mil due to persistent knee problem.
Its not a bad squad, if Marvaeux(or whatever he's called) ends up decent and Arfa makes a good comeback from injury then you have cover on the wings, Egghead looks far more consistent than he ever did at Utd.
If they can get one striker, and have Best/idiot brothers as backup, get a CB in then they've actually get a fairly decent squad in terms of cover. At which point they should start to be in the position to bring in a bunch of young/cheap players and watch a few break through and a bunch be not good enough, but with a good team to start with that's all they really need.
It's also worth thinking Newts, that come Jan, Newcastle can probably attract some decent players, in summer players would be wondering if they were joining a team destined for a relegation fight, come January, they might be thinking Newcastle, fighting for a euro spot and a good platform to a move further up the league