I've no doubt the Vive is the best piece of technology overall, but I'm still not convinced on room-scale for this first generation. IMO the seated experience still needs sorting first.
Yep I agree. I guess it does give them something the competition don't have, but it's early days and I'm not sure it's needed yet.
Personally I think both are a bit expensive if we want VR to take off and not die before it gets going, plus the spec needed to go with it. If VR gains mass market apeal we might be thanking the likes of Sony and Samsung.