• Competitor rules

    Please remember that any mention of competitors, hinting at competitors or offering to provide details of competitors will result in an account suspension. The full rules can be found under the 'Terms and Rules' link in the bottom right corner of your screen. Just don't mention competitors in any way, shape or form and you'll be OK.

JayZ review of the 5700XT Red Devil, don't OC, Undervolt.

humbug

humbug

humbug

Caporegime
Joined
17 Mar 2012
Posts
47,732
Location
ARC-L1, Stanton System
Interesting 5700XT Red Devil review from JayZ2Cents, don't overclock it, undervolt the card, that will get you better performance.

Performance is give and take RTX 2070 Super, he agrees with AMD's claim to think of this first Navi as a disrupter like Ryzen 1000 with later versions developing and growing from there.

Good card, for the first time in too long time from AMD GPU's, now i'm interested.

 

TrM

TrM

TrM

Associate
Joined
3 Jul 2019
Posts
744
Whilst I think the 5700/Xt is a good start and nice to see a new product from amd and not just another example 480 variant :)

But amd really need to take on the mighty 2080 ti really and the 2080 super to a degree for the past few generation amd and Intel have battled it out in the budget and mid range gpu section the 1060vs rx480 etc and price always seem to be competitive but NVIDIA are just running away with everything higher now I have recently brought a 2080ti for a little under 1 grand but seriously I know my credit card loves me atm the price is to high by a few 100s of pounds.

Now I’m not really liking the rtx stuff I think it’s to early and nowhere near powerful enough and not enough games support it. And the games that do a 1660ti running the game without the rtx stuff turned on gives better performance then my 2080ti with it on in bf5.

I hope amd bring out something to rival the 2080ti or even 3080ti when that comes out and brings on a price war if there both I pad with performance the. The price will be the deciding factor again which will be nice.
 

humbug

humbug

humbug

Caporegime
OP
Joined
17 Mar 2012
Posts
47,732
Location
ARC-L1, Stanton System
willhub said:
It seems a good 10+fps off the 2070S sometimes, now if 1+1 = 10 then yea it's pretty much 2070 super.
Click to expand...

Hitman:
5700XT 150 FPS
2070 Super 150 FPS (0%)

Metro LL:
5700XT 181 FPS
2070 Super 200 FPS (+10%)

Ghost Recon Wildlands:
5700XT 104 FPS
2070 Super 110 FPS (+6%)

ROTTR:
5700XT 141 FPS
2070 Super 155 FPS (+10%)

SOTTR:
5700XT 119 FPS
2070 Super 119 FPS (0%)

FC5:
5700XT 126 FPS
2070 Super 132 FPS (+5%)

You're right... Doesn't match up with what he actually said does it?

Still, 0 to 10% to a card where the 'cheapest one' is £75 more expensive, i think to get equivalent AIB range you're looking at £100+ more expensive.
 

TheRealDeal

TheRealDeal

TheRealDeal

Soldato
Joined
28 May 2007
Posts
10,071
humbug said:
Hitman:
5700XT 150 FPS
2070 Super 150 FPS (0%)

Metro LL:
5700XT 181 FPS
2070 Super 200 FPS (+10%)

Ghost Recon Wildlands:
5700XT 104 FPS
2070 Super 110 FPS (+6%)

ROTTR:
5700XT 141 FPS
2070 Super 155 FPS (+10%)

SOTTR:
5700XT 119 FPS
2070 Super 119 FPS (0%)

FC5:
5700XT 126 FPS
2070 Super 132 FPS (+5%)

You're right... Doesn't match up with what he actually said does it?

Still, 0 to 10% to a card where the 'cheapest one' is £75 more expensive, i think to get equivalent AIB range you're looking at £100+ more expensive.
Click to expand...


Throw in some titles that Favour AMD and that would look on par. Where is BF5 for instance, FH4 and other big games where the 5700xt has the edge. Pretty much all those games are Nvidia sponsored titles.
 

TrM

TrM

TrM

Associate
Joined
3 Jul 2019
Posts
744
LePhuronn said:
Yawn.

And when you're already over 100fps, how do those 10fps matter? I'd rather save the £75+ quid and get the card that's just going to improve over time and doesn't turn my screen into a blurry mess.
Click to expand...

every frame counts:) if you have a 144hz dispolay u want 144 fps:) sorry but its true
 

humbug

humbug

humbug

Caporegime
OP
Joined
17 Mar 2012
Posts
47,732
Location
ARC-L1, Stanton System
TheRealDeal said:
Throw in some titles that Favour AMD and that would look on par. Where is BF5 for instance, FH4 and other big games where the 5700xt has the edge. Pretty much all those games are Nvidia sponsored titles.
Click to expand...
Or Forza Horizon 4 where the 5700XT matches the 2080TI, where is that?

These arguments are stupid, please don't :)

LePhuronn said:
Yawn.

And when you're already over 100fps, how do those 10fps matter? I'd rather save the £75+ quid and get the card that's just going to improve over time and doesn't turn my screen into a blurry mess.
Click to expand...

Only if you use DLSS :D

LvqGzmE.png
 

TrM

TrM

TrM

Associate
Joined
3 Jul 2019
Posts
744
Darujhistan said:
Quelle surprise, big tech outlet favours Nvidia...

5700Xt is every bit as good a card as the 2070S and is a good deal cheaper.
Click to expand...

amd thoughare still all over the place though nvidia is the market elader for a reason not just becouse of tech outlets and biosed reviews. Amd gpu trail behind in a lot of games And the xt isnt as powerful as the 2070s so the 2070s will allways be pushed by people its a faster card better suport in a lot of games. Amd really need to up there game and start to take the fight nvidia across the board and not just budget and mid range. by all accounts well have a 3rd player in the gpu space and if amd are not carful they could loose even more market share and suport from dev treams
 

wellibob

wellibob

wellibob

Soldato
Joined
27 Mar 2006
Posts
4,051
It's a mid, range card. Still too expensive for what it offers (comparing the prices from yesteryear).
I'm all for AMD but we need a 2080s performer for the same money tbh. Will it happen probably not but the prices need to be realistic and affordable.
 

Darujhistan

Darujhistan

Darujhistan

Soldato
Joined
28 Oct 2011
Posts
8,407
humbug said:
I don't think this is, throw in Forza Horizon 4 and and everyone screams AMD Shill.

I don't think Jay is like that, this seems ok balanced to me. :)
Click to expand...

Well it's not even 10% to start with, there's a reason people have cast doubt. The sample titles chosen seem to favour NV by the look of it. Under 10% shouldn't even be considered a 'lead' because of variance in results and title balance.
 

humbug

humbug

humbug

Caporegime
OP
Joined
17 Mar 2012
Posts
47,732
Location
ARC-L1, Stanton System
TrM said:
amd thoughare still all over the place though nvidia is the market elader for a reason not just becouse of tech outlets and biosed reviews. Amd gpu trail behind in a lot of games And the xt isnt as powerful as the 2070s so the 2070s will allways be pushed by people its a faster card better suport in a lot of games. Amd really need to up there game and start to take the fight nvidia across the board and not just budget and mid range. by all accounts well have a 3rd player in the gpu space and if amd are not carful they could loose even more market share and suport from dev treams
Click to expand...

Oh come on..... its a fantastic competitor to the 2070S, its quicker than the 2070.

First iteration of RDNA and with lots room to grow more Shaders. its a flying start...
 

LeMson

LeMson

LeMson

Soldato
Joined
21 Mar 2012
Posts
4,285
TrM said:
every frame counts:) if you have a 144hz dispolay u want 144 fps:) sorry but its true
Click to expand...
With freesync no you don't, anything around 100fps is fine, we'll within freesync range really. Fast twitch yeah higher fps but then you drop settings :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom