Nature VIA nurture
Fixed that - a subtle difference but worth making.
Nature VIA nurture
If anyone is interested, there's a clip on youtube of Sam Harris reading from one of his books on the illusion of free will which expands on the idea and makes some very good points.
Absolutely wrong.
For a start and ill repeat a functioning brain does not need free will. [..]
Nobody has said it does.
A functioning mind, on the other hand does.
Either I do or you have misinterpreted their position. I'm guessing the latter.
If you don't have free will, you don't have a functioning mind.it.
Nobody has said it does.
A functioning mind, on the other hand does.
A functioning mind, on the other hand does.
I've already explained why and I've already explained why your claim that everything is predetermined and that isn't claiming that anything is predetermined contradicts itself.
But there's no point in me repeating myself again. You're not reading my posts and you believe that it's impossible for anyone to change their mind because you believe that nobody has a mind (predetermined responses to inputs is not a mind any more than, for example, water flowing downhill is a mind). So it's a total waste of time replying to you and I won't do it any more. Change the goalposts on the fly again if you like (as you've done already by changing "mind" to "brain" and "predetermined" to "decided by a god"). I won't take the bait again.
If I ever have children *shudders* I will bring them up in quite literally a house in the country, allow them to go to very select social hangouts, and nuture them.
I think a lot of what goes wrong in a childs upbringing is who they mix with and the whole "oneupmanship" that happens within a social group.
Nice post OP.
It's good to see some teenagers have a brain and think about life now and then, instead of just 'all being idiots'.
Keep thinking about life and enjoy it Ignore those who reply to you with 'uggh rubbish load of tosh etc' .......... it seems this is a forum to shoot down quickly and not recognise not necessarily what was posted but the fact in this case that someone younger was at least having a good old think.
When I was growing up if I was playing up I used to get a crack round the head or actually punished for misbehaving.