Midweek Football *SPOILERS* 3/4 March

I think as a football fan you'd agree with 90% of what Wenger says. I know I do, however the 10% "train going off the rail" comments (which all managers are guilty of) are the ones that get highlighted the most.

I think there needs to be, I dunno more consequences. Like Catermole, his tackle could never ever be interpreted as a complete accident, he was just no where near the ball, he was pee'd off from being pretty badly tackled but taking that out on someone is just wrong.

I'm thinking, if you get a red card, standard ban, if you say get a 2nd red, or get a red card and already have 5 yellows(kinda indicating you're a bit of a problem) that red gets you 3 games. If you've then got 10 yellows and get a red, or 2 red cards, then you grab yourself a 5-6 game ban. There needs to be consequences so the worst offenders actually realise its simply not acceptable.

But what certainly would need to happen is the FA to open up challenging or recinding completely incorrect yellows and red's. Lets be honest, the FA watch all the games anyway, they have people go through them for stats, its not hard to recind or award more red's after a game. For instance Ronaldo's yellow in the final, it was completely ridiculous, as was Cole's first yellow at the weekend.

Repeat offenders really do need cracking down on harshly. But at the same time overly punishing accidents is the wrong way to go. I don't think in any way Taylor jumped in to hurt Eduardo. A distinction has to be drawn, accidents get a normal ban, those who go about kicking people in an attempt to win games by hurting players need a whole other level of punishment.

Theres just little need at the moment for Catermoles, Nicky Butt's, Smiths, Bartons, etc, to not kick seven shades of blue out of certain players in an attempt to "take them out of the game".
 
Catermoles, Nicky Butt's, Smiths, Bartons, etc, to not kick seven shades of blue out of certain players in an attempt to "take them out of the game".

WTF? When was the last time Barton or Butt made a horror tackle? Barton is no worse than the majority of players and I can't remember a bad tackle from Butt since he's been at Newcastle (probably made one or two, but none stand out).

Cattermole has taken out about five players already this season, he's a disgusting player. Next time we play Wigan I want Barton to make a horror tackle on Cattermole.
 
I think bad tackles need more stern punishment, but don't all football fans want this ?

The game has survived bad tackles in the past, and will probably survive this.
 
You come across as if you have never played football.

I don't see much wrong with that last post. Especially the point about recinding incorrect yellows. How many times does a player get pulled up for something when a player is accused of fouling his opponent but doesn't make contact/A player dives and his opponent gets booked/A player gets accused of diving and gets carded. Also think divers that get away with it should be able to be punished retrospectiveley. Would certainly keep Gerrard, Ronaldo, etc. more honest. Though to be fair in Ronaldo's case, refs can't wait to produce a card against him. Surprised he didn't get booked for his savage attack on Taylor's forearm on Wednessay. The dirty winker.
 
WTF? When was the last time Barton or Butt made a horror tackle? Barton is no worse than the majority of players and I can't remember a bad tackle from Butt since he's been at Newcastle (probably made one or two, but none stand out).

Cattermole has taken out about five players already this season, he's a disgusting player. Next time we play Wigan I want Barton to make a horror tackle on Cattermole.

Barton hasn't made horror tackles of late because he hasn't been playing. To be fair he's less about jumping in to break someones leg than deliberately tripping people and shoving people over, he's "dirty" rather than dangerous.

But Nicky butt headbutted someone in his last game(maybe two back now), and he slids in late on just about everyone, he constantly rams into people, he's dangerous, dirty and afaik is about the leagues top offender at the moment. Sorry but kicking people out of games shouldn't be an option, not least because it spoils games in terms of entertainment and at the end of the day thats what it is.
 
But Nicky butt headbutted someone in his last game(maybe two back now), and he slids in late on just about everyone, he constantly rams into people, he's dangerous, dirty and afaik is about the leagues top offender at the moment. Sorry but kicking people out of games shouldn't be an option, not least because it spoils games in terms of entertainment and at the end of the day thats what it is.

I can't remember the last time Nicky Butt injured anyone. :confused: There's a difference between stamping on someone's leg (i.e. Cattermole) and kicking someone in the leg in tackle, if you don't want to be kicked playing football you should give up really.

Butt never headbutted anyone anyway, he pushed his head against Matt Taylor, with Taylor doing exactly the same.
 
Back
Top Bottom