OcUK Mafia game thread - Game 2

Wow.. I at least expected a few posts before pookie sharpened knives. I'm at work so haven't had time to fully considor the implications of last night's murder but it has certainly thrown a spanner in the works as to who I suspected as mafia.

2 initial thoughts for now until I get home.

I don't see the obsession with the late vote. I was undecided and decided at that point to register a vote against shami for a comment he made on day. But I have subsequently changed my mind on shami.

Pookie if I was mafia I would surely have sent you to sleep with the fishes last night? Being how you have been on a crusade to get me lynched.

I'll post more thoughts when I've had chance to mull over it all
 
Pookie Bear said:
False. I've said twice now that the beard comment was merely filler - I have one myself - however he, and now you, insist on using that to try and invalidate my position! It was the late vote, the changeable position, the lack of denials and the recent playing of the "pity me" card which have made him my one and only true suspect. It must be said that you've propelled yourself up the list of suspected mafia members, so I no longer expect any support from you. As for the others, yes, their vote will either exonerate or implicate them.
Click to expand...

Propelled myself up the list of a massive 5 people? One of which you are already certain is a mafioso despite the complete lack of evidence! So far for me everything points toward Kaiowas and with your attacks on Brabbinho and now me today I see your arguments as nothing more than an attempt to deflect any suspicion into any other direction than yours!
 
Brabbinho said:
Wow.. I at least expected a few posts before pookie sharpened knives. I'm at work so haven't had time to fully considor the implications of last night's murder but it has certainly thrown a spanner in the works as to who I suspected as mafia.
Click to expand...
No, I don't use knives, and I haven't killed anyone. You have. At least you admit you were wrong about murdering poor Gooner yesterday, but that's hardly a difficulty, seeing as his innocence was announced to the entire town.

Brabbinho said:
Pookie if I was mafia I would surely have sent you to sleep with the fishes last night? Being how you have been on a crusade to get me lynched.
Click to expand...
Yes - getting rid of the person who has rabidly pursued your lynching would do you a load of favours. I trust even that would have woken up the town a little.

K1LLSW1TCH said:
Propelled myself up the list of a massive 5 people? One of which you are already certain is a mafioso despite the complete lack of evidence! So far for me everything points toward Kaiowas and with your attacks on Brabbinho and now me today I see your arguments as nothing more than an attempt to deflect any suspicion into any other direction than yours!
Click to expand...
Yep - from nowhere to second on the list. That said, Brabbinho is still number one on it and that's not changing for anything.

Of course, you are welcome to start flinging accusations my way - Brabbinho is a mafia member and I have made this quite clear - you, he and others (some who are no longer with us) have made accusations which been proven to be false, and lead to murder. I have not murdered, via lynching or the knife in the night, anyone in this town. Can you or Brabbinho say the same? No.
 
Lets look at this sensibly. There is still a cop in this town. A cop who has had 2 opportunities to investigate.

Of the remaining citizens I can only see one person who is stating with any kind of conviction that certain people are innocent or guilty. It stands to reason that they are almost certainly the cop. Maybe those who aren't sure of what is going on should listen to them.

I'm pretty sure the mafia must know he's the cop by now so he's almost certainly going to get whacked tonight whatever I say here. If the town are going to have any chance of surviving this we need to listen to him now. Get rid of one of the mafia and use this experience to identify the second.

My reading on this town is that Pookie is cop. On the first night he investigated Brabbinho and has been telling us ever since that he is mafia. Last night he presumably investigated me which is understandable given my ill-judged witchhunt yesterday and explains why he was not calling for my head this morning.

Today we lynch Brabbinho, tonight Pookie is whacked. Tomorrow we work out whether Shami, Psy or Killswitch is mafia. Which of you want to prove your innocence?

If I'm wrong then I challenge the real cop to step forward and say so...
 
Pookie Bear said:
Of course, you are welcome to start flinging accusations my way - Brabbinho is a mafia member and I have made this quite clear - you, he and others (some who are no longer with us) have made accusations which been proven to be false, and lead to murder. I have not murdered, via lynching or the knife in the night, anyone in this town. Can you or Brabbinho say the same? No.
Click to expand...

The thing is your accusations are unfounded and have no substance to them whatsoever, it's my understanding that Brabbinho would have murdered you last night if he were indeed a member of the mafia, Egon was killed instead. Those are the facts, anything else is pure unfounded speculation upon your part and based on nothing! The only conclusion I can draw so far is that Kaiowas is somehow involved, looking at what has actually been said between Egon and Kaiowas and the fact that yesterday Kaiowas looked to be public enemy number one I can only help but assume yourself and Kaiowas are in the mafia and you are desperately trying to save your friend by deflecting blame in other directions.

Your behaviour is quite threatening and you have used aggressive means to try and take votes from the other townsfolk. It's quite telling that Kaiowas immediately voted for Brabbinho after you pretty much ordered him to. Very telling indeed.
 
Another busy day of arguing over who to lynch again!? :(

Whilst I'd like to trust Pookie and his insistence that Brabbhino is a member of the mafia I still fail to see any solid evidence either way. A late vote means little - especially considering I failed to vote at the end of the 1st day - surely that should make me public enemy #1?

Without any solid leads I don't like the idea of a lynching and although I was (and still am) suspicious of kaiowas and don't like how hard Pookie Bear is pushing for direct action. For now they remain my immediate suspects and they do seem to keep singing from the same hymn sheet so to speak....

More thinking required. I'm starting to fear for my life now too!
 
Actually, purely on the basis of his behaviour today I'm going to place my vote now. He's trying to force people into voting for Brabbinho when I can see almost no reason to do this. I understand the angle that he *may* be the cop and is trying to let us all know that while not actually saying the words for fear of being whacked by the mob, the only thing with that is it's so glaringly blatant that it's not really a veiled attempt at all. It smacks of trying to strong arm the weaker willed into taking his side which I don't think is the right way to be going about this at all. It wouldn't surprise me one bit if he was mafia and that the whole Brabbinho thing has just been part of the gameplan.

Vote: Pookie Bear
 
Pookie Bear said:
No, I don't use knives, and I haven't killed anyone.
Click to expand...

I was talking figuratively with the knives and given half the chance you would be killing an innocent man in myself.

Yes - getting rid of the person who has rabidly pursued your lynching would do you a load of favours.
Click to expand...

Yes as you are the only one who believes I am of guilty of anything.

Pschomonkee said:
Whilst I'd like to trust Pookie and his insistence that Brabbhino is a member of the mafia I still fail to see any solid evidence either way. A late vote means little - especially considering I failed to vote at the end of the 1st day - surely that should make me public enemy #1?
Click to expand...

Thank you. Though I don't suspect you have anything to do with the mafia :)

Kaiowas said:
I can only see one person who is stating with any kind of conviction that certain people are innocent or guilty. It stands to reason that they are almost certainly the cop.
Click to expand...

Does it? They could just be being very forceful to take away suspicion from themselves.
 
Initially, I thought he was a townie but he has been so forceful to the point of going beyond reason I can't accept that any more.

I'm still thinking it through but I think in most probability Kaiowas was the killer last night and Pookie is his conspirator.
 
Shamikebab said:
I'm just suspicious of the overconfidence.
Click to expand...

Pookie Bear said:
By delaying your vote, you're not putting pressure on anyone. Support me and vote now - before long we'll see where the battle-lines are drawn when the mafia see the net closing around them.


Well, you did contribute to Gooner's death. Get behind my vote and you'll not need to worry about me being a part of any mob at your door. I back those who back me.
Click to expand...

Indeed. This post set alarm bells off for me.
 
Having a read back and I'm now the last to vote for this day which means I can decided the fate of someone in the town....the power is rushing to my head! :eek:

If I understand the rules correctly in this instance a vote for Brabbinho would cause a tie, my vote (the most recent) to be removed and Pookie would face the noose! Infact the way the votes are currently lined up it seems that no matter what happens Pookie is going to meet his maker unless a massive vote switch occurs!

Just cause I can I shall throw the cat among the pigeons and state that now that Brabbinho has the necessary votes and knows it could he have pulled the greatest trick yet?

The evidence for me still points to Pookie Bear but I have started to wonder.....that said nothing can be done now though!
 
I've also found time for a recap and I reckon I'm now talking to just 2 people.

Shami - You're townie and you've been taken in by the mob. Don't cost us the game, switch your vote to Brabbinho.

Psy - You're also a townie. A townie who doesn't know what's going on and is being indecisive as a result. Do the right thing.

Everyone else has their positions and isn't going to change them for obvious reasons.
 
Last edited:
Even if I 'do the right thing' (whatever that may be) I alone cannot save Pookie - you will need someone else's vote of confidence and I'm still not seeing much in the way of evidence point to Brabbinho - share your evidence and maybe others will vote how you want?
 
It's hard to trust what you say Kaiowas, your vote was given over to Pookie so easily and it just seems really odd as to why you would do that. If Pookie was the cop then I imagine he wouldn't go around acting like he *is* the cop! It's a sure fire way to get clipped quickly. Not to mention the fact that Brabbinho would surely have killed Pookie last night based on the way the conversation was going yesterday. I think you are the two who are in league with each other.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom