Well, from my point of view, someone who's never seen that photo before, that is the immediate conclusion one comes to. Outside you, that guy, and/or her, no one else would know what they were doing, I bet they don't even remember it themselves, it really just looks like she blinked as she is shrugs her shoulders. In fact, it looks like her eyes are about to open.
It's not a criticism on the shot, it's how the image comes across. It's why I asked in the first place.