Red Dead Redemption Thread

Been a long time since I've let a review decide for me. Back in the days of buying GamesMaster regularly. :p


I've had to cancel my NaughtyBear pre-order to get this. :(
 
He then said I could have it 3 days early :)

For £1000 :(
Hah, always worth shopping at the independents.

The shop that's taken my mate's PS3 pre-order is allowing customers to collect their game the moment it's in, either tomorrow or Wednesday. I was surprised at how open they were about breaking street date too, the staff straight-up admitted it to us in the store.
 
I prefer 1ups rating system, they grade games rather than rate them per say. So they are awarded A* down, more sensible approach. Game lacking in some areas then grade falls.

They gave RDR an A btw, it fell short of A*
 
I've not read a single review all I needed to know was GTA4 + Cowboys + Shooting in the Face people on my friends list & any random passer by or Nun Whoever whatever gets it, Simples !!!
I've Always wanted to be that cowboy in Black that roams around shooting people just to hear the sound of his six shooter.:cool:

I'm going to have one hell of a steep learning curve to get over though as I am complete crap when it comes to shooting with a controller. :o
Who cares I'll learn in between Deaths. :D
 
ust finished BoGT in preperation for more Rockstar goodness :) Hope shopto manage to exceed epxectations again and get it to me on weds, although I doubt we'll get that lucky!
 
People on my friends list are playing it now. It came out at 12am in the US.

and someone set up a spoiler thread. I just managed to not read the spoiler at the top. God damn idiot.

Oh, and the first thing I am going to do in this game is get a bear to chase me into a small town with people and see what happens. :D
 
Last edited:
When will the n-out-of-n scoring system be done away with? A well-written subjective review should matter only; not some arbitrary numerical 'score'. How the frick can something as deep and complex as a computer game simply have a number slapped on it, deeming how good it is? Moreover, why do people flock to these scores like they're the Rosetta Stone of predicting whether or not you'll like a game.

Far too many statements like this: "9.8, so as good as Halo, then?". Good? Define 'as good'... As good compared to how much you liked Halo? Or good as in compared to how much everyone did? And how much is that? 9.8/10 people abso-****in'-lutely loved the **** out of Halo and wanted to mate and have little compact disc children with it while the remaining 0.2 people flushed it down the toilet?

The poor reviewer makes his/her notes, pours over the game for hours and hours, coming to logical and subjective opinions regarding every facet of a massive game and puts it all down into 3 or 4 pages of professional prose - to response "omg 9.8! lol ign gave gta4 10/10 and it were crapppp lol". If there was no numerical score stapled to the bottom of every review, perhaps people would READ the review and come to their own subjective and informed opinion instead of letting a number make the decision for them.

I agree to an extent but I still feel that the problem lies primarily with the consumer, many games jorno's will tell you themselves that the number is just a 'guide', if people rely solely on this number rather than reading reviews then that is the consumers fault imo, I'm not saying that I agree with numerical attachments to games reviews but I still feel that we are more to blame than the games journalists themselves, they do what they do out of consumer demand.
 
Last edited:
Heard that the character can't swim :(

No but they can wade.

As for scoring. It's never going to go away but I wish they'd ditch the decimal and just have a straight 1-10 or 1-5 or A-E. I can understand the difference between an 8 and a 9 but between a 84% and an 86%... not so much.

1UP nearly got it right but don't deserve any special praise, I mean... any scoring system where you can have an A- or a B+ deserves a slap.

And I've found my preorder...

Steven,
Thanks for shopping at Argos.co.uk on Wednesday 15 July 2009 .. Total (including delivery) £27.59 This amount has been charged to your card.

Yep I paid for it a year ago... I've been excited about this for a very long time...
 
Last edited:
Will they let it go out on Thursday though in the shops ? most won't release it until Friday the proper release date.
 
Back
Top Bottom