Show Us Your Motors!

Thats what I was trying to point out, that an opinion of a car cant possibly be a personal attack

Most people have slated the car in a personal way. Calling a car rubbish/crap etc isn't the same as saying "I don't like the styling" or "it's not to my taste"

GD thrives on kicking someone one way or another. When this happens it's very much a personal attack rather than just an opinion, which is what so many GD's try to fall back on when they step over the mark.


I do like Polos but (any car -ed) that looks like that makes me snigger :p

Which is fair enough if you don't like it. My point was more about a dig at someone being desguised (badly) as just an opinion.
 
Last edited:
No its not, saying a car looks crap means it looks crap, nothing more.

If you're lacking as much personality that you need to be completely defined by a car so get offended by the slightest criticism of it, you probably do need help though
 
Calling a car rubbish/crap etc isn't the same as saying "I don't like the styling" or "it's not to my taste"

It's exactly the same, just said in a less roundabout way. 'That car looks crap' = 'My feeling is that that car looks crap' = 'That car's not to my tastes'. It can only ever be the poster's opinion, so I don't think 'imo...' and 'my thoughts are that....' needs to be added all the time.

Must we really pander to the delicate in making a point? Maybe if this was a sensitive meeting of political leaders on the verge of war...but it so isn't.
 
These things always end up going the same way on here though though and it's never constructive. The guy obviously took offence so maybe there is something to learn from how you post and how people see it if your mearnt actually meant to be offensive.
 
It's exactly the same, just said in a less roundabout way. 'That car looks crap' = 'My feeling is that that car looks crap' = 'That car's not to my tastes'. It can only ever be the poster's opinion, so I don't think 'imo...' and 'my thoughts are that....' needs to be added all the time.

Must we really pander to the delicate in making a point? Maybe if this was a sensitive meeting of political leaders on the verge of war...but it so isn't.

There's a difference between pandering to the delicate as you put it to posting an opinion without being rude.

As I mentioned before I'm not bothered either way, it was just a point I noticed. I guess GD brings together a type of person who 'get off' on posting in this type of way.


These things always end up going the same way on here though though and it's never constructive. The guy obviously took offence so maybe there is something to learn from how you post and how people see it if your mearnt actually meant to be offensive.

Very well put.
 
These things always end up going the same way on here though though and it's never constructive. The guy obviously took offence so maybe there is something to learn from how you post and how people see it if your mearnt actually meant to be offensive.

And maybe there is something for the OP to learn from how he perceives things and what his expectations are when he posts pictures of his car on a public internet forum. When you decide to show your car off to the internet, you invite comments good and bad. It's how it works.
 
Last edited:
Let's just face it: It doesn't take a lot to make a more constructive post, but it's far easier to be a complete arse as it's an accepted standard here and has been for ages. People who have been on these forums for years and know what the place is like don't take offence or aren't really bothered either way, but for someone who doesn't know the nuances of motors or indeed the minefield that is GD you lot can come across as complete pricks some times.
 
Would you watch a movie where all the cast speak really politely to each other in a lovely way, even when expressing disagreement?

'Oh I say, I don't like the way you stole my stash, kind sir'
'Sorry about that, lets have some tea and have a chat about it'
'Excellent, I'll grab my companions from my vehicle'

Lets face it, sometimes brutal honesty is just less tedious.
 
Back
Top Bottom