Let me give a perspective from a victim of car-theft.
My first car was an old ford escort diesel estate, bought for a grand in 1994. I was on very low earnings and I loved that car. I'd just passed my test and it felt great. I was due to be admitted to hospital to have a minor operation and me and my dad had a walk down to the local pub quiz to take my mind off it. As we were apporaching our house my dad noticed mycar wasn't there. This was three weeks after buying it. I never saw the car ever again. To make matters worse, all my college work was inside it.
So, the car was never recovered and the perpetrators got away with it. Do I wish that they had crashed it and burned to death? Do I wish that they drove into a lake and drowned? Do I wish that they got beaten and buried alive like in "Casino"?
The answer is yes. Preferably all three while they're in hell. I swear, if I ever found out who they were I'd find a way to have them killed.