St Georges is one of those cultural artefacts that hasn't been bastardised by the capital virus though it has to be said that keeping something relevant (even if through a vice like drug abuse) does keep it alive to a degree but how long before it's lost any meaning at all? Using something that is inherently negative and malignant to maintain a religious holiday is something that I think describes a dying (stagnant) culture rather than a vitalised one (not that St Georges day being even less relevant is a great sign either).
St. Patricks Day vs St. Georges Day - in England
- Thread starter Ace Modder
- Start date
Soldato
It's because England is crap and the Celtic nations are better is one view
Soldato
Cornwall as a separate nationIt's because England is crap and the Celtic nations are better is one view
Soldato
if we could put landmines on the welcome to Cornwall point we would , after a few years of living here we all think , "turn around and **** off back to where you came from"Cornwall as a separate nation
Soldato
btw its wine night, most of you know i am from Yorkshire
Soldato
It would have to be - Cornwall is about as Celtic as Blackpool. They all vote Tory FFS lol. Christ even in the council elections Mebyon Kernow are humiliated.
I do wish people would stop talking rubbish about Cornwall - it's a bit childish.
Soldato
Depends who you mean by "they" tbh as half of the people who are ****** off with the rat race come here for a better life.
Maybe the peppe who have made a bundle in Fulham and come to Polzeath or bring their pension lump sums are this "they"
On the hole there does seem to be more passion for Cornwall by People who live here than passion for England, nearly every village has it's traditional like obby oss , Bolster day , carnivals ect ect St Pirrans day is a very big thing here .
I wish people wouldn't bundle millions of people together and just call them they though.
It's a bit childish
Edit footnote/ it's amazing how many people from up country pretend they live here by sticking a Kernow sticker on the car think this says a lot
Last edited:
Soldato
- Joined
- 16 Aug 2009
- Posts
- 7,750
George is not even a real saint he's been demoted, un-sainted by the RC church its just a retelling of the greek Perseus and the gorgon myth
Used to be till about two centuries ago its been eroded by general english-ness in wales 150 years ago the majority were welsh speakers today its less than a quarter and there are no monoglots its all part of a cultural erosion processCornwall as a separate nation
Caporegime
Because the St Georges cross is a symbol of racism and Crusaders.
Im quite sickened that you would even consider celebrating genocide and religious intolerance.
Im quite sickened that you would even consider celebrating genocide and religious intolerance.
I'm sure Patrick was an upstanding fellow that never did anything untoward with his once pagan flock.Because the St Georges cross is a symbol of racism and Crusaders.
Im quite sickened that you would even consider celebrating genocide and religious intolerance.
Soldato
It’s racist for English people to be patriotic.
Soldato
It’s not racist to be patriotic but the most visible English patriots also seem to be quite racist which is unhelpful.
St Patrick’s Day has undoubtedly been helped by being co-opted by a lot of people around the world and was never really a nationalist day. It’s more of a chance for people to cling to what little Irish identity they have and have a laugh.
St Patrick’s Day has undoubtedly been helped by being co-opted by a lot of people around the world and was never really a nationalist day. It’s more of a chance for people to cling to what little Irish identity they have and have a laugh.
It does seem to be the way now :/
Soldato
I am sure that the French are equally as patriotic as we Brits if you scratch the surface. And it is not racist to be patriotic. Loving one is not hating another.
Last edited:
Soldato
Why would we celebrate it? Should we look at every other country's celebrations and then immediately require an English equivalent? Most countries have a saint, not just England and Ireland. And St George himself is the patron saint of many places other than England. Why don't they celebrate St George's day?
Last edited:
Soldato
Never set foot on English soil and probably said "Where" when asked about his opinion of England
Might as well have Father Christmas as the patron saint.
And as for St Patrick
Might as well have Father Christmas as the patron saint.
9 Things You Didn't Know About St George
We separate fact from fiction to try to get closer to the truth behind the legend of St George.
www.english-heritage.org.uk
And as for St Patrick
It’s a product of a terrible legacy of what “being English” stands for and reminds most non English people of.
Like it or not but celebrating being English is not a great look to most of the rest of the world. Very few other countries look upon their history with the English with any level of fondness. They always see a former opponent or oppressor from the old Empire days.
There’s no such stigma attached to being Irish.
Let me put it this way, think of how English people view the French in general. Now multiply that contempt considerably and that is how many people view the English.
Obviously this is an overgeneralised view and not about individuals but about national identities in general.
Like it or not but celebrating being English is not a great look to most of the rest of the world. Very few other countries look upon their history with the English with any level of fondness. They always see a former opponent or oppressor from the old Empire days.
There’s no such stigma attached to being Irish.
Let me put it this way, think of how English people view the French in general. Now multiply that contempt considerably and that is how many people view the English.
Obviously this is an overgeneralised view and not about individuals but about national identities in general.
Last edited:
Soldato
The fact that the Irish gets a bank holiday and time off for St Patrick and the English don’t for St George’s day doesn’t help.
If the British government wants people to become more patriotic, that would be a good start.. we get less public holidays than most other countries.
If we had the day off then we may have the time to celebrate it, wrestle it back from the idea that it’s racist and overtime it can become a tradition where we can get drunk. Heck it may even become an income with people flying in to celebrate it and the government can claw back the money from it not being a working day.
If the British government wants people to become more patriotic, that would be a good start.. we get less public holidays than most other countries.
If we had the day off then we may have the time to celebrate it, wrestle it back from the idea that it’s racist and overtime it can become a tradition where we can get drunk. Heck it may even become an income with people flying in to celebrate it and the government can claw back the money from it not being a working day.
Can confirm, the only time feel and kind of English patriotism is when we give the French a good kicking in some sporting event. Otherwise I couldn't give a stuff.