Well I said I'd never see it but I didn't count on being ambushed by my best mates "Batman is awesome" 8yo boy earlier today
So there's me (huge '89 Batman fan) and my missus, my best mate and his wife (those 3 don't have a single "lets watch a movie" bone in their body, never seen Star Wars, MCU etc) and my best mates Batman worshipping 8yo. So whilst the other 3 spent most of the movie chatting and generally mostly ignoring it, me and the kid gave it a good go and, to be fair to the kid, he stuck it out longer than I did, even if most of of the Batman nostalgia was wasted on him. However, he didn't really enjoy the film outside of seeing Batman and when he wasn't on screen it was hard for him to follow the story.
For me, it was a bad as I'd expected with just literally 1-2 moments where the film script/story wasn't awful. I'm no fan of Miller as a person nor actor but the "new timeline" version of the Flash was just unbearable, which had the opposite effect of then making the OG Flash actually seem well acted in comparison, which throws my "he can't act" thoughts into a spin and means that he must have either decided himself to act like a **** or been told to act like a **** by the director in his "new timeline" version. Either way its a disastrous choice to make him soooooo unlikeable, despite understanding why they needed to go that route (
for the "purple villain" part) when they could've done the same with far less obnoxiousness.
I saw the complaints about the CGI during the hyper-speed sections looking bad and absolutely agree which is yet another disastrous decision by the director/studio, although lots of very shoddy CGI was still there in the normal speed shots too, way too much for me.
In the end this was, at best, a 3/10 for me. It had a few moments when it shone which was almost entirely Batman and a wasted virtually cameo-like appearance from Kara/Supergirl, but that was so heavily outweighed by an awful story, awful director choices, an unlikeable lead and a dead-end Universe that this was never going to be a smash hit.
Now I've just got to wait a few years til the kid is old enough to watch the '89 Batman with me, then maybe the Nolan Trilogy, if he's still into Batman by then of course.