Caporegime
Bob Beamon? His long jump OR has stood for nearly 44 years! And it took someone nearly 23 years to beat it.
The Greatest Olympian Ever?
- Thread starter Pigeon_Killer
- Start date
As impressive as it was, it was done at an altitude no games have gotten anywhere near since. It's essentially like setting a track record with a massive tail wind.
Permabanned
They said tall men could never run fast in a 100 meters.... Bolt has redefined that view.
To go from 9.86 to 9.72 (Usain Bolt's first world record) took just under seventeen years. Taking roughly the same amount again off the record — 9.72 to 9.58 — has taken Usain Bolt fifteen months.
Soldato
Just think, if darts had been an Olympic sport from the beginning Phil Taylor could be the greatest Olympian ever...
Soldato
wiggins will overtake redgrave as gb's most successful olympian today
and his done it
Soldato
Don't know about the best, but my personal favourite has to be Michael Johnson, he was such a beast on the track and with such an individual style.
Edit: Some of his highlights:
*Only man to win the 200m and 400m gold at the same olympics.
*Held the 200m WR for 16 years.
*Still holds the 400m WR.
Edit: Some of his highlights:
*Only man to win the 200m and 400m gold at the same olympics.
*Held the 200m WR for 16 years.
*Still holds the 400m WR.
Last edited:
Carl Lewis and Asafa Powell are both 6'3"
That's not "redefinition," that's just really impressive, within the existing definition of the sport.
Do you believe he was clean really? I read this on the greatest olympian article on the bbc yesterday...
Carl Lewis perhaps should for testing positive for banned substances three times before the 1988 US Olympic trials, and then reacting with a petulant, "There were hundreds of people getting off," when pushed.
I can't help it, I'm a cynic
. I don't think Bolt is clean either. Just the same as when Gatlin was on fire I didn't believe he was clean either. I think it might take a few more years to catch Bolt but they need to look after those samples for a later date True enough, let me put it another way. If Phelps was the fourth best swimmer in the 4x400m medley for 5 olympics in a row while others better and faster in the team came and went would we be considering him as an all time great because he was tagged on to the talent of faster individuals in a team?
I admire he consistency over all those years while others did come and go but I don't think it even beats Phelps individual honours let alone with a team as well.
Associate
- Joined
- 24 Jan 2010
- Posts
- 2,141
Really we're comparing apples and oranges.
There aren't many athletes who are able to compete for as many medals as Phelps. I mean look at the deal weightlifters get. You have to master 2 diciplines, (it used to be 3), for only a single medal.
If the olympics favoured weightlifting as much as it does swimming you'd have more than two lifts, and each would have their own individual medal.
Sure, it'd still take an exceptional athlete to win them all, but weightlifting has had "phenoms" like Phelps before... although they only ever get to compete for 3-4 medals over the course of a 12-16 year career.
There aren't many athletes who are able to compete for as many medals as Phelps. I mean look at the deal weightlifters get. You have to master 2 diciplines, (it used to be 3), for only a single medal.
If the olympics favoured weightlifting as much as it does swimming you'd have more than two lifts, and each would have their own individual medal.
Sure, it'd still take an exceptional athlete to win them all, but weightlifting has had "phenoms" like Phelps before... although they only ever get to compete for 3-4 medals over the course of a 12-16 year career.
Caporegime
It's the nature of team sports. The point is, Redgrave was at least the 4th best rower in the England and arguably the 4th best rower in the world for 16 years.
Soldato
- Joined
- 8 Mar 2007
- Posts
- 10,938
Quite and Hitler's 'snubbing' of Owens wasn't even race based but nationality. Hitler only personally congratulated the German athletes, Jesse Owens could have been a blue-eyed, blonde-haired white man he still wouldn't have got the personal congratulation from Adolf because he was an American.
Furthermore Owens in his own words states Hitler did not snub him, but his own president did...
Permabanned
Quote:
On Saturday he stunned the sprinting world, easily winning the 100 meter dash in world record fashion.
Every commentator and expert kept talking about how Usain Bolt was too big to be a sprinter, too tall and bulky. And I happened to agree.
Sure, he won the 100 meters—and he'll probably easily win the 200m—but how is he using the fact that he is 6'5" as an advantage? How much money is he going to make as a sprinter, in what will be a short career?
Soldato
Yordan from bulgaria deserves a mention. Not the best athlete in the world ever, but its incredible to be doing Olympic level gymnastics in your 40's
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yordan_Yovchev
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yordan_Yovchev
Man of Honour
Do you believe he was clean really? I read this on the greatest olympian article on the bbc yesterday...
Carl Lewis perhaps should for testing positive for banned substances three times before the 1988 US Olympic trials, and then reacting with a petulant, "There were hundreds of people getting off," when pushed.
I can't help it, I'm a cynic
Short answer is no, I don't believe Carl Lewis was clean although I'm not convinced he was any worse than others of the same era. I think it does affect any claim for him to be the greatest of all time though.
Like you I've got a certain amount of suspicion when anyone decimates a World record, especially as Jamaica has a number of the best runners in the World right now. They've traditionally been good but not quite of the level where no one else gets a look in as far as I can remember. It's a bit sad that this is a first thought now but it appears to be the way sport has gone. I do hope he is clean as I'd love to believe that occasionally there is someone who is leaps and bounds ahead of the rest but history suggests a certain degree of skepticism is merited.
Soldato
- Joined
- 8 Mar 2007
- Posts
- 10,938
Absolutely but I don't think that's a feat deserving of the best Olympian we have ever produced let alone the world.
Yeah just like when America had their batch of cheats. It must just be part of the training camp
Andre Cason, Missed the season through injury in 92. Turned up in 93 and ran 9.92 and was part of a team to tie the 4x100m world record. I always wondered what happened to him...
I guess it's got to the stage that it's all just part of the game. If Greene was clean I'm a ninja.
Soldato
Another issue with Carl Lewis - as the video above shows - he was a complete ***.
Soldato
- Joined
- 8 Mar 2007
- Posts
- 10,938
Yeah but he enters 8 events every Olympics so he's bound to pick up more golds than most other people who at most enter 3 or 4 events (often only 1 though).
His achievement is fantastic but I'd like to see a table whereby the amount of events you enter is taken into account.
I don't get why there are so many swimming events anyway, like the 100m butterfly for example. You've already got the 100m freestyle where people can do the butterfly if they want.
Caporegime
But no one would win the 100m freestyle doing the butterfly... Freestyle means front crawl. Which gets us back to the argument about there being too many different events when some strokes are clearly better than others speedwise.