I found another NATO style strap, this time one which looked better online from Roobaya in Germany. It wasn't cheap at £49 from
Amazon but I thought it was worth a punt.
It was shipped via UPS and arrived this morning. I opened the package to find a very nice looking box.
Inside the box...
Looking very good - Long side is quite long and the short side nice and short...
Here it is fitted to the watch. I had to go with black adapters because they didn't have any space grey in stock but that doesn't matter.
It's great that the short side is nice and short, the buckle sits in exactly the right place, along the edge of my wrist, not the underside.
However there are some issues.
The long side isn't quite long enough, it doesn't fold back in as far as I'd expect. The inside of the strap against my wrist is quite scratchy and uncomfortable and there really aren't enough holes for a fine adjustment.
And the 'keeper' on the long side is utterly useless. I don't know why it's there, it's just all horrible and sticking out.
If this had been a tenner, I'd have kept it but for £49, I expect far better than this. It's going back, not recommended.