Poll: The official Football Manager 2008 thread

Would you buy FM09?

  • Yes definitely

    Votes: 145 40.3%
  • Perhaps, depends on the reviews/bugs

    Votes: 102 28.3%
  • Definitely not

    Votes: 113 31.4%

  • Total voters
    360
If you have spare wage budget Marc adjust the transfer budget from that if you are able, very good way to raise transfer funds fast if you need it. Just don't go too far or you wont have wages left for any signings you do get in.

SCM
Already done. ;) Only had £151k at one point. Couldn't change the ruddy budgets as it was transfer budget into wage budget only for a time. Worked it out and got £6.6 out of the tight fisted board.
 
Make sure you guys check out or pick up Olazabal from Barcelona "B", he's quite cheap at the start of the game, and turns into this around age 21:

82wpvte.jpg
 
Some nice tips there BoomAM. :)

Scouting them all now. Trying to get VDV to replace Scholes so that I can choose from Anderson/Van Der Vaart which I think would be a nice situation to be in. Only got £6.6m at Man Utd so I will have to wait until the end of the season and get some money for him.

Structured deal.
If he hasnt changed club yet, you can get him for between £12 & £16m.
Offer something like £5m up front, then a further £10m over 24 months. Then wack on something like 20% sell on, and extra £2-3m after 40 goals, and they should bite.

Basically with structured deals, if you offer them more than they ask, but over a longer time period, they'll have more of a chance of accepting. As they'll get more money, and you get the player early.
Remember to keep an eye on all your clauses though.
If your offering X amount for several players a month, make sure that your actual income each month is greater than this, or you'll run yourself into debt.

:).
 
A few of my tips for FM08:

-- Tuia is a good long term buy.
He's a DC with the potential to be better than Barzagli, one of the best DCs in the game.

-- VDV is a bargain at £13m. He's just as good as Kaka for my Milan side.

-- Structured deals is the way to go if your short on cash. Little up-front, loads of clauses, like x amount over 6-12months.

-- If your after some good midfielders on the cheap, then look at Milans team.


-- Cassani

-- Okaka from Roma is a good buy

-- If you move quick, you can get Mascherano

-- Akinfeev: I cannot stress how good this guy is. Ive loads of keepers over the 07 & 08 games, and Akinfeev is by far the best.

yea agree with a lot of the above. Milan are a good team to loan players from if you are in need due to the quality they have in their reserves. Just about to chase Gourcuff myserlf

re Keepers, have you tried; Diego Cavalieri

seems to be the no.1 keeper to me and have the price of akinfeev.

Re Calaio i wouldnt buy him but its true that he is my top scorer after 8 games with 10 goals. he misses an aweful lot though...
 
Little update withmy game. Still cant get a job :( :p

Spurs asked me and I said no. Dont want another premiership club. Spain and Argentina places came up but they picked other managers. No other european clubs have come availible yet and its been a season already.

Just got to wait really till the chance comes.
 
Yep I agree. The number of ruddy MCs my scouts find is annoying! Find me strikers or wingers or keepers. :mad:

Although I am finding all too often that my scouts will come back from a region and tell me that they found no players at all! I mean all I want is a list of decent players aged 18 or younger.
 
Few more players to look at;

GK - Eros Corradini - 18 - Parma - Good for a team mid prem or so, PA of about 169 apparantly. Bargain at £10-40k, he gets better at about 20 years old.

AMRLC - Silva - 21 - Valencia - Brilliant winger, and can play in the centre. Def worth purchasing, if your top 8 prem or so.

MC - Jeremy Toulalan - 24 - Olympique Lyonnais - Good player, good for any team.

AMC - Diego - 22 - Werder Bremen - Brilliant AMC, similar to Van Der Vaart.

DC - Ezequiel Garay - 21 - Racing - Similar player to Kompany.

AMC - Samir Nasri - 20 - Olympique de Marseille - Similar to Van Der Vaart.

ST - Fred - 24 - Olympique Lyonnais - Good player, would be good for any team, scores goals often.

ST - Vagner Love - 23 - CSKA Moscow - Same story as Fred, when i signed him, scored 23 in 19 apps.

Few other names to throw in;

Dinijar Bilyaletdinov - Lokomotiv Moscow
Angelo Palombo - Sampdoria
Luis Jimenez - Ternana
Lenny - Fluminese
Alessandro Tuia - Lazio
Oier Olazabal - Barcelona

Some of the ages might be wrong - but theres a few good signings for you.
 
Oh you mean like "Player X could be the next Player Y"?
Sort of, although theres that as well.

Im on about scouting as well.
For example, if i scout Okaka with my best scout at the beginning of the game, im told he's not worth diddly squat.
Yet 2 seasons later he's the best thing since sliced bread?
 
Yeah I see what you mean. I've seen the same player mentioned by several people all playing FM08 so I know he has to a) have the potential to be good and b) become ruddy good yet my scouts say there isn't much point in getting him. Unless the game is making the scouts compare the scouted player to my squad. So if the current ability of a player is nowhere near the current ability of the best player I have in that position the scouts say he's rubbish even if his potential ability means he could rival or even beat my equivalent players in the future?
 
That issue has been sort of fixed, with scouts saying that player X is the x best in that position.

Although what annoys me also is several players who aparentely are no-where near good enough to be better than player X, is rated 11th best, is classed as a 'decent' player by my scouts? huh?:confused:
 
Haha yeah. I love that. Player X would be the 11th best central midfielder in the squad. And he's a decent buy. Right so someone who is about as good as a rubbish reserve team player is a decent buy?

Edit - Jimmy Briand for £13.75m + 20% future fee. Worth it?
 
Last edited:
Haha yeah. I love that. Player X would be the 11th best central midfielder in the squad. And he's a decent buy. Right so someone who is about as good as a rubbish reserve team player is a decent buy?

Edit - Jimmy Briand for £13.75m + 20% future fee. Worth it?

YES i love Briand always has done awesome for me in old games havent got hold of him on FM08 though :(

Also about the lad who posted Nasri, has some decent stats but as a AMC he is awful imo, gets into decent positions but his finishing is almost has bad as my goalkeeper :(
 
Yeah I see what you mean. I've seen the same player mentioned by several people all playing FM08 so I know he has to a) have the potential to be good and b) become ruddy good yet my scouts say there isn't much point in getting him. Unless the game is making the scouts compare the scouted player to my squad. So if the current ability of a player is nowhere near the current ability of the best player I have in that position the scouts say he's rubbish even if his potential ability means he could rival or even beat my equivalent players in the future?

BUT Do you ever have a scout that tells you a player is amazing who turns out to be a dud?

NO because scoutage is broken and has been for numerus years. I.e they can only be wrong 1 way, but no matter how good the scout is they will never be right,

i.e take Okaka, say i had a scout who was 10/10 potential and ability scouting attributes, and he says Okaka is Average, surely using a scout which is 20/20 Ability and potential will tell you the truth?

NO he lies too...

However, if you find a real chump and use the same pair of scouts, the bad one will not come back and claim him to be a wonderkid when he isnt...

So why can they be wrong in one dimension but not the other? bad coding.
 
I see what you mean. My scouts only ever say someone will be brilliant. Sometimes I doubt this so I check the player out in the Editor and find his PA is quite low.

I would say the scouting is probably the poorest area of the game for me.
 
Looking for some new defenders as I'm now in the EPL with Forest. I've signed Fabio from Man Utd on a Free, Kerlon for 10m. So need some DC, and a LB.

Who should I look to buy? I have abour £10m left, and am in my 3rd season.
 
Back
Top Bottom