You make reasonable points - that doesn't make them easy to swallow
No it doesn't
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/acff2/acff25e8e0f3553880111f7dfb81686cf78ab820" alt="Frown :( :("
Such is the world we live in right now. But competition and price warring will only help us long term once this forsaken year, COVID and the various backlogs it has caused have passed.
Previously AMD have had nothing that could challenge Nvidia quite so directly on absolute performance, at least without using pricing to do so, for quite some time.
As can be seen in the reviews, at 1080p and 1440p, RDNA 2 is actually faster in many cases than the current Ampere models, even if Ampere pulls away at 4K. That just simply was not true for the last few generations, albeit Vega 56 at its reduced later prices was of decent value relatively.
It's easy to forget, but the VAST majority of gamers, STILL game at 1080p. 1440p is going on to become the premium gamers resolution, whilst 4K is still niche, and will be for a few years yet, given panel pricing.
1440p 90+Hz refresh rates are just starting to become more majority affordable. These cards are great, and even potentially more performant, for many, MANY people, than the current Ampere lineup, because even the vast majority of gamers, even gamers who spend thousands on a rig, will have 1440P, simply because they can get a high refresh rate panel without spending silly money.
4k and 8k are great, but these cards are clearly built around majority resolution targets, and still do well at 4K. RT is still first generation PLUS level, and as the consoles are built with even less performance than this; the majority of games will target this, with some higher optional levels. DLSS alternatives are coming, but right now Rasterisation is still king, and these cards are still very good, as proven by the outliers where even the 6800, a £550 card, is beating Nvidia's 3090 at 1080p.
I don't doubt there will be 4K improvements in RDNA 3+, in the coming years as 4K becomes more relevant for more people, but right now people do need to remember that 4K PC gamers are a definitive niche, and the vast majority of 4k screens out there are 60Hz.